Thursday, December 8, 2011

EU Parliament Decision on Maspero incident 2011

Protection of Freedom of Religions and rights of minorities or interference in the internal affairs of the State, within those parameters the EU Parliament passed a draft resolution which was the last in many measures taken by the International Community as a response to a protest against religious discrimination turned into a bloodbath in Maspero Area in Cairo on 9 October 2011.
The EU Parliament, On 27 October 2011, passed a draft resolution on the situation in Egypt and Syria, in particular the Christian Minorities. The resolution strongly condemned the killing of protestors in Egypt, expressed solidarity with the Egyptian people in their struggle for democracy, while noting that since March 2011 tens of thousands of Copts have reportedly left Egypt called upon SCAF to put an end to the emergency law, as it violates the rights of freedom of expression, association and assembly and urged the Egyptian Government and authorities to put an end without delay to military trials of civilians.
In her address to the Parliament, Catherine Ashton, Vice-President of the Commission/High Representative of the Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy stated, “We were all shocked and appalled by the violence against a peaceful demonstration by the Coptic Christian community that led to the death of 25 people, with more than 300 injured.
These clashes run contrary to the whole spirit and goals of the revolution and the aspirations of all Egyptians – of all backgrounds and beliefs.” She added, “I made a statement calling for calm and restraint and an investigation so that those responsible for the violence can be brought to justice.
I urged and I urged the authorities to protect the right to demonstrate peacefully, and the right to freedom of religion or belief – one of the most fundamental of all human rights.” Commenting on this, a Diplomat from a European who deals with EU Parliament matters, who preferred to stay anonymous, stated “the resolutions of the EU Parliament are recommendations and not mandatory. They are directed to the European Commission and the Member States. These resolutions are used more as public relations tool because in many incidents the views of the Parliament do not coincide with those of the Commission. They are more of political messages to States and not many implications on the EC relations with Egypt will take place at this stage based on that resolution.” Contrary to that, Ms Heba Morayef of Human Rights Watch confirmed that the impact of such resolutions should not be underestimated because although they are non-binding, the resolutions of the EU Parliament have impact on the EC and policies of its member States. “The Parliament is pushing its Member States to be adopt a more robust approach with regard to supporting Democracy and Human Rights.”
While this is not the first time the EU Parliament tackled the issue of human rights in Egypt, freedom of expression as well as the rights of minorities, but this was comprehensible under the Mubarak regime. The Mubarak regime and its repressive approaches were behind the 25th of January revolt and they have always refused such resolutions as contradictory to the principle of non-interference in the internal affairs of States. Yet, reflecting that no change has taken place so far, the surprise in Ashton’s address was in relation to the situation after the revolution. This surprise is shared by many human rights organizations, including Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, who called for accountability to those who were behind killing the peaceful demonstrators. Ambassador Fathy El Shazly, Former Assistant Minister of Foreign Affairs for European Affairs, contradicted the views of many officials that the principle of non-interference in the internal affairs of States is absolute. He stated, “Egypt must respect human rights and freedoms in order to avoid any criticism from the international community. The era of absolute power of the state against its citizens is over and States should not be left to torture and violate the human rights of citizens without accountability. It is time for a clear law to regulate the issue of places of worship. Building churches illegally is not appropriate, but the lack of necessary regulations to build places of warship is a problem. If we solve the problem, Egypt will not be subject to international criticism.” He added, “We cannot adopt two standards, Egypt was a locomotive in the Organisation of Islamic Conference in order to have international intervention to save the Muslim minorities in Bosnia and Kosovo against the oppression of the Yugoslav regime at the time. Hence, we should set our internal affairs in place in order to avoid international accountability.” Ms Morayef stressed that the continuation of discrimination against Christians with regard to the building and renovation of their places of worship leads to the violations. She added, “In the last 4 years, incidents of sectarian violence were all concerning building legally unauthorized churches. Recently, the government acknowledged that this issue should be solved through the unified law for places of worship to replace the ancient law that is still in force until now. Moreover, the continuation of the unfair law will lead to further breaches to it by building other unauthorized churches.”
In Egypt in the aftermath of the incident, SCAF requested the Government, on 10 October 2011, to establish an independent commission of inquiry in order to investigate the events and supposedly bring those accountable to justice. In the evening of the same day, the Government established the Commission and issued decisions with regard to the speedy conclusion of the unified law for warship places and amendments to the Penal Code to consider discrimination as a crime. Moreover, the Supreme Council for Human Rights has established another independent Commission of inquiry in the Maspero incidents. Both reports are expected to be published by the end of the week. Ms Morayef confirmed that a problem exists in all the incidents of using disproportionate violence against peaceful demonstrators, not only the Christian demonstrators in Maspero, and the lack of accountability to those who do that. This constitutes a clear violation to the rule of law and provides impunity to the perpetrators. She confirmed, “The way the state has been dealing with incidents of sectarian violence is not satisfactory. We didn’t see indictments in all the incidents that took place since the church of the Two Saints explosion in Alexandria in Christmas last year, passing through Atfih, Embaba ElMenya and now waiting for the outcome of the Maspero inquiry. The rule of law and fighting impunity should replace the old policy of using sectarian violence to achieve political goals, while leaving the victims in a weaker position subject to vindication of their rights by the State.”

latest news!

In an unusual briefing evidently aimed at Washington, Gen. Mukhtar al-Mulla of the ruling council asserted that the initial results of elections for the People’s Assembly do not represent the full Egyptian public, in part because well-organized factions of Islamists were dominating the voting. The comments, to foreign reporters and not the Egyptian public, may have been intended to persuade Washington to back off its call for civilian rule.


hence... Tahrir is not representative of people .. parliament doesnt represent people.. who does? you ya ro7 mama ??

Tuesday, December 6, 2011

THE RE-INCARNATION OF THE OLD REGIME IN EGYPT

THE RE-INCARNATION OF THE OLD REGIME IN EGYPT

Namira Negm

This constitutes a hypothetical assessment to the current situation in Egypt. The least we can describe it with is a lucid situation where no one knows what it will lead to in the next few years.

A Plan or no Plan:

A persistent question that did not leave my mind since SCAF assumed the responsibility of the State in February 2011, are they implementing a plan to get us out of the current situation or they only react to the acts that take place on a case by case basis. Many scholars and analysts differed in their point of views. Some believed that it is all an American plan and the road map for the transition has already been assembled with SCAF members with their counter parts in the pentagon. Others disagree and they believe that SCAF has no plan, the situation is overwhelming to the leaders of the army who stayed for ages away from the political scene and now they found themselves trapped between the people, the old oligarchy, the foreign interests and their personal interests. They have all been appointed by the ousted president and they worked under his command for decades, they won’t be interested to meet his fate or even close.With that in mind, it is a bit confusing…

however, the answer might not be a simple one but there are few elements to consider:

1. The point of unity during January- February 2011 was to put an end to a dictatorship. All factions gathered in the squares of Egypt in millions and the rest gathered in neighbourhood watch groups to protect themselves and their families from the thugs in the absence of Police forces. This was and still is a source of danger to whoever wants to rule Egypt through a Plan.

2. The Military leaders managed to get rid of the dictator.. i.e. siding with the People and became national heroes.. yet, the threat to their power is imminent if the point of unity remains in place.. so now it is time to DIVIDE AND RULE. A quick remedy that will not only split the people in trivial arguments and distract them from what I do, but also it will assist me in putting my house in order and stop any criticism that may arise for the military stepping into the scene with full force.

3. REFERENDUM: interesting enough.. all of us, as expected of course, were more than happy to cast our vote..Many of us knew at the time, that it is absurd to go for such referendum.. the split started between the Egyptians and we started to speak of law and politics and not Egypt… we started to debate:

a. The composition of the Committee.
b. The appropriateness of the timing.
c. The problems entailing amending a dead constitution and bringing it back to life.
d. Shall we draft a constitution first or elect a president and parliament first.\
e. A non-existent fuss over Article 2 regarding the Principles of Shari’af. Many other little details.

4. The Referendum was a brilliant tool to achieve the DIVIDE TO RULE… it worked.. and people thought they will get stability by saying YES… the outcome of the vote was 18 million turn out at polling stations.. lot of Media influence and good for calculating what can take place next.. in fact, the most sensitive issue that we voted for, consciously or unconsciously, that we gave SCAF full powers.. a blank sheet to run the country.. SCAF, in accordance with the Constitutional Declaration has the right to assume the powers of the President and the Legislative Power until both are elected. These powers were not met by any responsibility towards the people… i.e. no means of accountability… what is better than this for someone in the leadership position?!

5. Yet, another controversial issue that came out of the referendum was issuing the second Constitutional Declaration, which incorporated much more provisions than those that we voted on. Moreover, the ones that got green light in the referendum were changed in the Declaration, including that SCAF will be the one putting the new constitution to the people for a public referendum and not the newly elected President… interesting isn’t it?

6. Since then, things seemed to be back to normal and the people shushed anyone that complains because the Media brainwashed the people that stability and economic growth depends on ending demonstrations. They didn’t mention that as long as the Military Junta is in Power, there are doubts that stability will be brought into the political scene and that is one primary factor for investments and economic growth. Sporadic incidents took place all around the country due to the lack of security and rule of law implementation… yet, it was always the people that are blamed not the ones in power.

7. This was the situation until Maspero Massacre, which ignited lots of animosity and calls for SCAF to give up power. It was meant to take the shape of Muslim/Christian sectarian violence… but failed big time…yet, it did divide the people over who started and who killed who?

8. SCAF under pressure from all sides, internally and externally, decided to hold elections on time as planned. November will be the beginning of a 4 months daunting elections to elect members of the 2 houses of Parliament… regardless of the fact that SCAF members meet with political factions and then decide something else, which is another way to divide the players on the political scene, people were eager to go through the institutional legitimacy in order to get stability.

9. All of a sudden, under huge pressure, SCAF realized that it has committed a grave mistake by leaving everything in relation to the new constitution in the hands of civilians that will be elected in the Parliament… from the composition of the Assembly of the Constitution to the privileges and immunities of the Army. So, their remedy was ElSelmy’s Document… through the Deputy Prime Minister, a good tool to impose a document before elections and to divide and rule just before the elections… let’s see who can still mobilize the street against SCAF and let’s put all the political factions in clash again with each other depending on which interests are at stake.

10. So far, the outcome is one “Kandahar Friday” led by Islamists and as of the following Saturday all political factions asking SCAF to step down and give power to a civil council to run the interim period until we have a president.. brilliant situation through which it has divided the people further, managed to leave Islamists do their utmost to get the majority in the parliament and keep the idealist revolutionaries screaming in Tahrir and killed in Mohamed Mahmoud.. and, under the pretence it is for the sake of the Country, the elections will be held by hook or by crook on time… which it did!

11. Elections became a target and goal in the minds of people.. again this is what will bring us stability and guess what? Through our votes.. our voice will finally be heard.. so, people were also adamant to have elections to get rid of the dilemma that they don’t understand and they are mostly not part of it except through home discussions with family and friends. They forgot that elections is simply a tool through which people express what they want in order to reach a democratic system.. it is not democracy in itself.. but anyways.. it became as such for the moment.

12. Now, miraculously, the first phase of the elections is almost over, the run offs are going to be on Monday 5 December 2011 and another imposed legitimacy on the people are played so well. Tahrir is getting emptier and people are watching for the moment. The highest turn out in an election in the history of modern Egypt… and all is celebrating democracy… stability is near! And an end to the Military Junta ruling is close… until June 2012 and Egypt will be heading towards a better future!Now, is this part of a plan or not? I believe it is. The plan is reincarnating the old regime in new figures, names, political ideologies and through elections.

The diagram below shows who the parties of the plan are and I will describe how it works in my point of view:

SCAF
US PLAN
Polical Factions Islamist Factions


The Plan is an American one, this assumption is based on the following:

1. Naom Chomsky’s theory: the American interests in the region will be directly hampered by real democracy. The reason behind that is the growing sentiment of animosity towards the American policies in the region, especially after the Iraqi invasion, and its strategic alliance with Israel that proves always to be on top of the American Agenda in its dealing with the region. Moreover, we should not forget that although Egypt is not a wealthy oil nation, but it has the Suez Canal. Through its location, population, history and demography its power should not be taken lightly.

2. Tariq Ramadan, a Professor of Contemporary Islamic Studies at Oxford University, mentioned that the members of the youth movements, including some of the members of the 6th of April Movement and the role that Google played, through its support to Wael Ghoneim, showed that all of them in a way or another were used as part of the plan. May be they knew, maybe not… but the trainings abroad since the year 2000 to the members of the youth movements on how to gather people under one slogan and avoid contradictory issues in order to mobilize the masses, the service that Google provided to tweet over the phones in the absence of internet communication in Egypt was remarkable opposing to a refusal to provide similar service to the revolt in Syria.

3. SCAF members and the Egyptian institutions were not at all prepared to draw a proper plan. We are talking about a flawed system that used to work only to serve one person and his family later on for decades. Hence, the corruption is not only in financial or administrative aspects.. but it led to putting unfit people in certain positions… hence, it is very difficult to believe that the plan is all made within the borders of Egypt.

4. The United States have been sending delegations, researchers, scholars, NGOs.. all funded by different parts of the American system to conduct business in Egypt and do thorough research about every aspect of the human life in Egypt together with the involvement in its industry and economy. Hence, the US has enough information and studies in place to use when necessary to preserve its interests in Egypt.

5. The US is not the sole implementer of the Plan. It does that directly, through its contacts with SCAF members, Muslim Brotherhood and other Political players and indirectly through its allies in the region. After the Egyptian Revolt, we had a new Baghdad Pact forming against revolutions by Monarchies through the invitation addressed by the Gulf Cooperation Council to Morocco and Jordan to join. Funny enough that Jordan had a request pending to join the GCC for ages, and Morocco is way far from the vicinity of the Gulf… yet it is time to join forces to engulf the revolutions in the Arab Countries in order to preserve the powers of the Monarchs. Furthermore, this is evident from the financing of Saudi Arabia, Qatar and Bahrain to the Salafis and Muslim Brotherhood. It will be naïve to assume that all the millions of dollars spent by the GCC members on specific sect, that lean more towards oppression rather than democracy, is done in isolation from a US laissez faire policy or upon direct approval of the US Government.


6. Mossad and CIA are not far from the work done on the ground undercover. In a lucid situation with lax security, time is ripe for those to conduct many of what they want in Egypt. Whether the latest news of arrest and deportation or putting into trial Israeli or American citizens are all based on solid information or not. Yet, some of them might be valid cases of espionage against the stability of Egypt.

7. Lack of leadership to the revolutionary forces ease up the job for all the internal and external players. It is easier to divide people without a leadership than those gathered behind one.

What is the content of the plan?Reincarnation of the old regime is the answer, how will this be done?

Through the following:

1. SCAF is concerned about keeping itself out of the trouble. Hence, all what most of these members care for is their safety and preserving their immunities and privileges. Since, they took over the country; they are working through Divide to Rule and issue bills to preserve their position and their colleagues who are now considered civilians. This amounts to impunity not only immunity. But they want to be away from any accountability before the people, whether when it comes to the Budget of the Military, their shares in 25% of the Egyptian Economy that no one knows to which extent it goes, their shares in public institutions, among which are; Heads of specialized Councils, Heads of Public Sector Companies, Governors, Ambassadors and others. Is this is preserved with the least amount of damage… well and good.. Preferable, but if not.. then they will fight for it.

2. Civilian Government and a Civilian President will be acceptable to SCAF as long as they will take one step backwards while keeping an eye on everything and preserving their interests. Hence, controlled democracy won’t hurt as long as the constitution either expressly gives them the powers of being the guarantors of the constitutional legitimacy and that the Military Budget is out of touch or at least implies that this will be the situation.

3. Following the reincarnation of the regime with new faces and even new ideologies will not hurt SCAF or affect it in anyway… and it will work well to preserve the interests of all those who see the revolution as a threat to their interests, whether the US, Israel or the Monarchies of the Gulf.

4. When another boiling point that was brining the second wave of the revolution to a success, SCAF in arrangements with the US, decided to react to this wave of the revolution by stating the following;

a. They are still supporting the revolution.

b. They are trying to keep the territorial integrity of the state.

c. Confirmation that SCAF doesn’t want to stay in power much longer than necessary.

d. They will change the government of Sharaf as the people want.

e. Elections will be held on time.f. Presidential election shall take place by the end June 2012.

5. With this, SCAF appealed to the general public to stop the bloodshed in Mohamed Mahmoud Street and to go for the elections that will bring a fair, democratically elected Parliament as a first step towards stability. The parliament will have the power to choose the 100 members of the Constitutional Assembly. Then we will have a Constitution and an elected President. SCAF will then leave the playground to the elected bodies and President to run the country and by then it would have fulfilled its perceived mandate.

6. Hence, we will have new figures.. people will celebrate democracy while at the same time. It will change nothing except limited things.


The Goals of this plan:

1. From an American perspective, it will serve all purposes;

a. Their interests in Egypt.
b. The balance in the relations between Egypt and Israel will remain in place.
c. They will show the world and the Egyptian people that they have stood by their morals and ethical values with regard to Democracy.
d. The Egyptian people will get their stability and believe that they are finally ruling themselves and they will get back to their homes to stay dormant for a decade or more.
e. It will preserve the American interests in the Gulf States when the people there will see that Egypt is dormant again and of the Monarchs the Egyptian role is not back full power like the 50s and 60s or the days of Mohamed Ali.
f. A new Sykes-Picot Plan will be drawn to the region in absence of its representatives except those who are allies to the Americans. The plan will be in place while the people are still struggling to get rid of the oligarchs in the institutions and business in their countries. Hence, there will be no say for those who will be the subjects of the plan.

2. From the perspective of SCAF, it will serve the following purposes;

a. SCAF will look like the hero in the eyes of the Egyptian public; it has preserved the stability and the integrity of the state when it was in dire need to do that.

b. Prolongation of the periods of elections for both houses of the Parliament and the Presidential will get the people bored of the game of democracy with nothing changing in their daily lives. (Divide and Rule again + people freak out from the ruling of islamists when it gets too close to reality)

c. Further confidence that the Military is the only solid institution in the Country to play the role of the guardian of the Constitutional legitimacy.

d. SCAF will leave the forefront of the power scene without any damages to their benefits, immunities or privileges.

e. SCAF will have a President, who is an X-General, that will run for the elections in the last minute, or one of their allies from the civilians. Then they can take a step backwards and be in control from behind the scene.

f. Burning all the islamist factions (old rivalries since 1954) by allowing them to run freely for elections, contrary to the legal system that rejects the use of religion in politics, through allowing them to get the majority of the Parliament. A parliament with very limited powers and million electoral promises that should be met in a short time. Hence, islamists will fail to deliver, beginning from the ultra orthodox Nour and Jama3a Islamiy’a who won’t be able to achieve their goal by establishing a rule based on theology and the Muslim Brotherhood, who are the oldest in the streets that will fail to deliver its promises, especially with security when they cannot form a government.

Other political factions and coalitions are mostly so far in the minority and they can always claim that they are new to the game and if they deliver their promises of a civil state and social justice in the constitution… they will get back to their constituencies as achievers.

What is missing here is one aspect that has been under estimated for decades and until now, even after 2 waves of the revolution has been underestimated. This is the EGYPTIAN PEOPLE.

The following square completes the image of the political scene in Egypt.

Egyptian Poeple SCAF
US PLAN
Polical Factions Islamist Factions



The entire plan is based on the assumption that people, the regular Egyptians, will be sick of the youth with political views and ideologies and all what they will care for stability and getting back their lives to normalcy.

This proved right in the referendum, the run-offs of the first round of the Parliamentary elections and from the pattern of voting towards the freedom and justice party which was able to use the heritage of the Muslim Brotherhood and Gulf money to deliver services to the poor areas where the government was totally absent in order to gain majority in the Parliament. This has also been proven right when fewer people joined in the demonstrations between February to November when the calls were strictly on political and legal issues.

Yet, the Friday 18th of November 2011 demonstration that was led by islamist factions against the Military interfering in the composition of the Constitutional Assembly and following it demonstrations that are led by those who contributed in the 25th of January Revolution (without formal contribution from most of the islaimst factions) for almost 10 days proved otherwise. Yes, the latter ignited clashes between the people and the authorities in the street of the Ministry of Interior and all around the country but it failed to gain the sympathy of the majority of the people. The main call was to put an end to SCAF ruling now and people were lost between the need to have minimum stability with SCAF running the show during the interim period and the lack of confidence in the reasons behind the second wave while the elections were so near. This proximity led to less support by the majority to those in Tahrir and their supporters all around the State. They were only mad at the brutality of the security forces but they didn’t know who to blame.


To sum up, all these plans will fail only by the persistence of the People. History proved that when people are persistent to fight for their rights and freedoms they get it. If they fail to or cease to fight, only then plans will prevail not the will of the people. When it comes to Egypt, it will be a long term struggle for power, yet, I am positive and confident that the WILL OF THE PEOPLE SHALL PREVAIL.

THE RE-INCARNATION OF THE OLD REGIME IN EGYPT2

This is a follow up to the last post on the reincarnation of the old regime in Egypt...


The latest developments that took place in Egypt in the last few days can prove that there is something fishy about the elections and the new Ganzouri government.. this post will attempt to assess them.. there is no solid grounds but only reading the facts and trying to understand what is going on...

1. the run-offs in the first round of parliamentary elections:

a. the turn out of people to the ballot stations was very low in comparison to the day of the main elections, there were many reasons brought up by different people, including, inter alia;
- the negative effect of the media with elite scrutinizing the illiteracy of the population for making wrong choices.
- the fear of the people from brining themselves to dooms day because of their choices, including the Nour Party and the last statements made by some of its members in the run offs that made people scared of the unknown.
- people thought that there will be no fine for not voting in the run offs in comparison to the main day of elections.
- those who wanted secular parties lost interest because of the outcome, they've already lost the majority to the Islamists.
- those who wanted islamists, some decided there might be no use to go because they have already gained the majority.
- the complexity of the electoral system for the regular egyptians can well be a reason for refraining from going again and again.
- avoiding the long queues that people have to bear in only a week ago.. so why would they leave their work, errands or housework in order to suffer in a queue in something that they don't have real interest in.
- buying votes and using electoral tactics were at its top in the first round, but not the same in run offs in certain districts.
- only those who were fighting for a right, a view or they know what is it all about went out of their way to vote.

b. the outcome of the run- offs shows that the Muslim Brotherhood took one step backwards in districts where the run offs were between one of their members and a secular or real independent one ( elkotla almasrya, elwafed or el adl), but they were very forceful in districts where the run offs were between one of their members and a salafi member... they even made deals with copts in Alexandria to make sure that Shahat, who was the main speaker for the Nour Party, will lose.

c. this indicates what? there is a deal between the brotherhood and SCAF, and if it is not a deal then coordination in order to pave the way to specific distribution of power in the upcoming parliament that will serve the intrests of both.i wouldn't go back to the choice of the members of the constitution committee that proposed the amendments to the 1971 constitution before the referendum in which only the brotherhood was represented from among all the politcal factions to prove that there is coordination.. but it is evident from the different statements mede by the members of the brotherhood.. they will accept to leave the Military, its budget, privilleges and immunities intact.. even if it amounts to impunity.. it is fine as long as they will get to power (TV show with one of their prominent members) moreover, avoiding any clash with the military at this stage is profitable and appealing to the general public.. hence.. it is fine to go for it..also.. some statements were loud calling for SCAF to leave the parliamentary majority to form the government .. then almost appologies for that tone and accepting the facts and law in the constitutional declaration.

d. possible alliances between the brotherhood, elkotla and other secular parties.. will crush the salafists and will give the brotherhood more power in dealing with different issues in the parliament and as a tactic in negotiations with SCAF.

e. MB seems to have learnt a little bit from 1954 experience, although there is massive lack of trust between the Military and MB but the latter is going to keep a low profile in order to get to power before they start overtly into a real power struggle.. SCAF is playing the game of the carrot and the stick with the brotherhood.. you get seats in the parliament and i let go of the foreign funding.. yet.. if you step on boots you will suffer.. i already scrutinised you among other politcal factions that you are all either clients to foreign interests via relations and fundings or traitors via trainings abroad to destroy the country..so, people can only trust the military..


2. the Ganzouri Process:

1. appoint a very old PM.... NDP.. stayed forever in the system...
2. obedient..
3. happy to be brought from home so he will do as he asked
4. give him the same amount of power of his predecessor and he won't complain
5. amend the constitution in order to give him some presidential powers for the interim period.. which will eventually be the powers of the newly elected president in june 2012 and prolonging keeping all the reins of the game in the hands of SCAF.

how will this be done?

first let us look at the time frames of elections and constituion:

1. elections for both houses of the parliament will be done in March 2012
2. if they start their work in March, they are supposed to choose the members of the Constitutional Assembly in 6 months. this means from March until September 2012.
3. the Constitutional Assmebly has 6 months in order to draft a constitution, i.e. from September 2012 until March 2013.

4. a decision has been adopted by SCAF that Presidential elections will be held at the end of June 2012... what will be the powers of the new president? there is a need to a law to limit his powers, otherwise, having the legitimacy he can do what he pleases, like what Sadat did in 1971..

5. the Constitutional Declaration must be amended in order to ensure the existence of a legal framework when a president is elected.. these should be very limited.. exactly like limiting the powers of the Parliament..

6. this has to be done in a very subtle manner and indirectly.. if it is done directly like Elselmy's document.. the country will rise again..

7. the calls of revolutionary was to bring over a care taker government with real powers.. SCAF will do that in its own way.

8. appointing one of their obidient guys, he will confirm that he got real powers.. and he even announced that there will be amendments to the Constitutional Declaration in order to get some of the Presidential Powers.

9. in June 2012, the people will elect a new President, with no consitution to decide on the parameters of his powers..

10. the Constitutional Declaration replaced the old Constitution and the country is being run under it.. when the new President is elected, his powers will be derived from this declaration.

11. these powers will be the limited powers Ganzouri will accept as a PM for the caretaker Government...


if the power struggle between SCAF and MB is not imminent...because it is in both their interests to form a tactical alliance with SCAF in the leading role... and let's not forget that SCAF is the first one that gave MB the golden opportunity to get majority in syndicates and Parliament in their entire history since 1928..

YET, the real power struggle which has started with the second wave of the revolution will eventually come in its THIRD WAVE... it will be tough.. it will be brutal.. BUT IT WILL COME and the POWER OF THE PEOPLE WILL PREVAIL.. History proved that THE POWER OF THE PEOPLE ALWAYS PREVAIL.

Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Tahrir 22-23 November 2011

">why Tahrir now? expect yes.. but what happened.. does anyone know? many of us who went to Tahrir were asking that question.. how and why it all started? the response was.. many of us didn't go to Tahrir on kandahar's Friday.. not our call... nothing happened .. everyone I talked to confirmed that Friday night- satuday morning around 100-200 people decided to stay in the square.. some arre just regular demonstrators and some were the injured or the families of the martyrs of the 25th of January.. eveything in the square was normal.. traffic and all.. the all of a sudden they found themselves in a cordon by the security forces and they started to make phone calls to tell their friends, either come for rescue or don't come but I may perish in a while...
a bit by bit the number started to increase in the square to fight back the brutality of the security forces.. more and more people saw, heard or knew from friends what was going on and decided to go down.. that was the situation until Sunday night.. yet, we are still talking about few thousands... Sunday evening in my classes, I've found out one of my students got hurt, 3 others were in Tahrir on Saturday night.. we discussed what was going on and all of a sudden a student from a class next door told us that fighting erupts in Tahrir and there are news that the bridge has been closed.. I decided to stop lecturing and bring to the screen live coverage from Tahrir, we talked about what is going on and most of the students were on one side.. what is happening is inhumane.. nothing has changed since February and I told them this is the second wave of the revolution.. couldn't continue with lecturing and decided to let them go few minutes earlier than the class time.
on my way home, I talked to few cousins, old students about what was going on in Tahrir and wanted to get a live picture of what ESA going on on the ground.. they were between the square and Mohamed Mahmoud street. all confirmed, the square is ok.. the security forces try on and off to barge in but the youth in mohamed Mahmoud and falaky are banning them from reaching the square.. Tear gas, rubber bullet, khartoush and sometimes live ammunition were used.
I was so tired to go on Sunday night, but I managed to join in Monday and Tuesday evenings- nights.. experienced not only tear gas but this weird effect of burning face, eyes and running on and off when there are warnings of raids by the security forces towards the square.. tried to donnate blood at last el3einy hospital failed big time... the aftermath of the experience so far is as follows:
1. egyptians when they want to do good they can.
2. political elite together with the army are damaging the country.
3. inhumanity is engraved in the mentality of the security forces ( brutality in beating, snipers on top of buildings, shooting the small little spot used as hospital next to mohamed Mahmoud street around 3 times in one night to ensure more death toll only takes place in Israel! now in Cairo...and other forms of inhumane treatment that seems to be an asset to them)..members of state security tried to access the square armed from locations they know they might not be searched, but they got captured.
4. media effect in distortion is amazing, the fight is ongoing and continuing in mohamed Mahmoud to prevent the security forces from reaching Tahrir, yet.. media is talking about the reason in a different context.. they're fighting in that street because they want to barge in the ministry of interior headquarters which is located in the same street.. Monday night/ Tuesday morning at 2am.. all members of the ministry withdrew all of a sudden... so, protesters started to take over, created a cordon around the premises of the ministry to prevent anyone from attacking it or barging into it.
5. some people claiming to be the honest people of abdin joined the security forces in the fight, while capturing one of them.. the revolutionaries found out that he was a member of the security forces (amin shorta)
6. tear gas and the gas that have been used today have a grave effect, burning in the eyes, skin, feelings of suffocation and dire need of fresh air.
7. it is true that the gas that has been used for 2 or 3 days now aginst the protectors is use in Chemical warfare. some of my cousins are scientists and they took the canisters and the remaining of some ammunition to the labs and they foud out that they contained CRS ( that is the abbreivaition they used). this material is one enlisted on the dual items list that can be used in chemical weapons.
8. crimes against humanity not only humane rights violations are taking place on the hands of the security apparatus in Egypt. I'm not
specifying the police forces because they work in tendem and under directives of SCAF .. so I consider them one unit.
9. the US will keep losing further ground with the Egyptian people by supporting SCAF tonight, together with those elite in egypt, who ignored condemning what is going on in Tahrir and putting demonstrators with no weapons on the same footing with those using traditional and WMD against them!
god bless egypt with the Egyptians who are the real asset to this country when they appreciate that they belong to Egypt and Egypt belongs to them.

Sunday, August 28, 2011

Family and influence

interesting enough that when we speak about ourselves, we don't necessarily speak of our families and their influence on our lives... sometimes we speak of books that influenced us.. people that passed through our lives.. and sometimes we speak about the inner circle of our upbringing.. although.. this is the first circle that shapes us to a great extent..

i always claim that we are the reflection of the house that we were brought up in... and i believe i am one good example of that.

i am coming from a family of lawyers.. well politicised.. since i was a child.. after few greeting sentences, the discussions float between politics and law.. my dad was a Nasserite.. yet, my maternal grandparents with whom i used to spend a lot of time when i was a child.. had more colourful experience when it comes to education but they were anti-Nasser. My grandfather, Dr. Mahmoud Diab, who was one of the first few physicians in Egypt specializing in Otolaryngology. yet, he was known in the medical syndicate that he is more a politician rather than a physician. when he was young, he wanted to join the law school, but his father pushed him to join the school of medicine... but his passion for politics never seized to exist.. he was an amazing reader, he had books stored everywhere to the point that we have donated his library to bibliotheca Alexandria in order to let the people benefit from this amazing collection of books. he was one of the founders of the Muslim Youth Association, yet he was against the Ikhwan and their role in political life.. when they invited Hassan Elbanna to hold his meetings in the MYA headquarters after the Movement was banned in the aftermath of their role in killing el Nokrashi Pasha, he told Elbanna that it was a big mistake to change the course of action of the movement and to get involved in politics and he used to say that the latter admitted that it was not the best means to go for politics and mixing it up with the da'awah. he was against the veil and backed empowering women without breaking the traditions. he was a very strict, direct and correct man. in order to complete this picture, one can't dismiss speaking of my grandma, Fatma Fathi, she was one of the first 12 girls that were sent to receive higher education in the UK, when at the time Egyptian girls get their education up to the primary level and used to work as teachers only. she left Egypt in 1919 and finished her university studies in 1927. she was the first woman in Egypt to specialize in Botany. she received her degree from Bedford College London. she was a very strong woman, she had great expectations in her life but society and reality bites. she worked all through her life in education and suffered a lot from her colleagues and even her family. i remember that she used to say, if i came in your generation i wouldn't have married. she had married my grandfather, who is her cousin, but the difference was massive from someone brought up, during the years that shaped her personality in the UK and another who was brought up between Cairo and the Country side. she was also against Nasser, she only used to admit that he was a leader, but she used to say that he is the reason that peasants became rebellious against them. she was a landowner and that dominated her perspective of course. i admired both my grandparents for their will and strength. My grandfather was the Director of Elmounira hospital before he retired, and he used to go to his clinic until few years before he passed away. he wrote books and never stopped reading. My grandma had her own library and she had a vision. she decided to study Botany. coming from the country side and owning land, it was important for her to develop her own property through science.. she implied a lot of her education in her property and things in the land are not the same since she passed away. she held up to traditions. whenever she went to pay a visit in the country side, she used to take off her city clothes and dress up in the black galabya, the traditional dress of women in the country side. she suffered a lot in her marriage due to the major differences between her and my grandfather. traditions were what pushed her to marry him. she wasn't able to manage in the house of teachers (special dorms for female teachers working in a city other than theirs). she moved to Cairo, rented an apartment, furnished it and took her mother to live with her. few months later, her elder brother decided that he wanted to take his mum. hence, with no choice left other than abide by his will, her mum left with the brother. my grandma, who can't live alone in her apartment because it was unacceptable at the time for a single female to live alone, had to leave her apartment, sell the furniture and get back to the dorms. when my grandfather, who loved her dearly since childhood, proposed to her, she accepted and lived with him in major ups and downs for almost 55 years or more.

now, reflecting on their experience, as an adult i understand the massive differences they had. A traditional Egyptian man, well educated didn't make much difference. he was still too traditional to accept the fact that his wife might be better than him.. she was well educated, strong, presentable and rich.. it seems a fatal combination for many Egyptian men to take until this day.

by all means, one can't fail to identify how these people affected one's personality. brought up in an environment that puts education as a priority, very politicised shaped the way i pursued my life.

my choice to go through the law school, was made after many logical debates with my father, who didn't want me to waste my high grades.. and wanted me to make sure that i don't want to join the school of political science or mass communication before i sent my papers to the administration. yet, i held to my choice which was taken since the high school. i thought, it is important to learn my rights.. law education can give me bigger space to choose. i wanted to be a diplomat and i got to know the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, would favour more law graduates because in the recent years there were few law graduates who joined in and they need people with legal expertise and background. i thought, i will sit for the ministry's exams.. if it works well and good but if not, i will have a real profession to lean back on. my father was a prominent lawyer.. if i work with him and take over the business, that will not be a bad option. if i want to work in the media, i can do that with my education, i can write articles and publish books. i can be a politician and read and analyze politics.. with the law education. so.. i didn't change my mind, and i stuck to my choice to join the law school.. a step, definitely not regretted.

to be continued..

Friday, August 26, 2011

Islam and destiny of man

these are parts qouted from the book Islam and the Destiny of Man.. it is very touching strong book.. i am still reading it and this will be regularly updated.. but i have read lots of books about islam, writen by Muslims and Converts.. this is by far one of the best... i almost cried twice while i am still in chapter 1.. i believe it is amazing how far we get to know more when reading about our own faith... how far the rest of us really need to get to the core of the religion and faith and feel comfortable in their own skin... and to know that the heart of our faith is beautiful, forgiving, enduring and much more.. if we just understand the message of the monotheistic religions.. our lives around the globe will be much much better. MAY GOD SAVE US FROM OUR OWN IGNORANCE!

I decided as I put it to myself to sow a seed in my heart, to accept Islam at once in the hope that the seed would one day germinate and grow into a healthy plant. I will offer no excuses for this, and would blame no one for acusng me of insincerity and a false intention. But it is possible that they may be underestimating god's readiness to forgive human weakness and his power to bring forth plant and fruit from the seed sown in barren ground.


I said, " no intelligent person nowadays believes in the god of religion!" he looked at me rather sadly before answering,"on the contrary, nowadays intelligent people are the only ones who do believe in god."

No one can live happily in constant disagreement with his fellow men and women, nor can he engage in argument with them since he does not share their basic, unspoken assumptions. Argument and discussion pre-suppose some common ground shared by those involved. When no common ground exists, confusion and misunderstanding are unavoidable, if not anger. The beliefs which are the very basis of contemporary culture are held no less passionately thanunquestioning religious faith.

I had allowed myself to be carried forward by the prevailing wind, and this was where the wind had set me down.

The saying of Mohammed, god gives for gentleness what he will never gove for harshness.


A Muslim, by this definition, is anyone who is able to make the confession of faith in sincerity, bearing witness to the fact that god is one, without a partner and without associate, and that Muhammad is his messenger to humanity. Since human beings can not read the secrets of hearts, the judgment as to sincerity rats only with god.

Vice plays it's tribute to virtue by masquerading behind the mask of religion- or of a political ideology- and wickedness walks the streets more confidently when decently cothed.

Quite spontaneously, without thinking what I was doing, I raised my hands and said, ' lord, here I am. Do with me as you will!'

I saw myself then as too sceptical, and worldly to be a 'religious person' as the term usually understood, but iwas under a compulsion to accept and adhere to what I found utterly convincing. This was the predestined homecoming.

I tried to show what it means to be a Muslim and to consider doctrine, history and social life in the light of the revelation which is the source of faith, as it is of a civilisation and culture constructed by human beings, god and bad, wise and foolish, out of materials crystallised from that source. But the whole, which reflects the divine plenitude, cannot be caught in any net of words. To every statement I would gladly add a formula of great significance in the context of Islam, a formula which indicates that god knows best, he alone knows truly, and that those who speak or write must always keep in mind their relative ignorance an the limitations of their perspective, just as the living must always keep death in mind. Wa Allah a'lam.