it is amazing how we forget that walking in the streets for women can be a normal daily business without harassment. Those of us who travelled a lot or used to travelling then reside in Egypt for sometime forget how is it to be normal..
something was never worth reflecting on... all through our lives when we were kids in Egypt, discrimination was part of the upbringing.. all the time you are reminded that you are a girl and that you should be dressed properly... you should behave, you should talk properly and if a visitor is coming to the house you have to be in an appropriate attire... some of these rules are also imposed on boys but others are lax...
so, anyways... after being in Cairo long enough in the recent years, my friend Marwa and I are travelling and we are in different countries but in the northern hemisphere. We were chatting the other day and she said it was so nice to walk in the streets normally like before... so my response was we have forgotten how is it to be normal... isn’t that true.. probably those of us who are brought up in the same manner will relate to that so much.. probably also, those women who were brought up in Egypt and never travelled either can relate to this...
the difference in the streets of Egypt today in comparison to our childhood is the hostile atmosphere women sense when they are walking or driving.... it is not only about hissing and verbal or sexual harassment and abuse in the streets.. but also the sense of freedom of walking without being monitored..
one thing that used to bother me a lot recently that people in the streets or even in shops doubt that i am not Egyptian, some even start to talk to me in English.. at the entrance of some places, like museums, they insist to see my ID.. although of course i speak in our dialect..even when i walk with foreign friends, they speak to them in Arabic and to me in English... it is really something bothersome to me... i am Egyptian from tip to toe!! so, in a discussion with a friend, reflecting on why i am doubted as a foreigner... he said.. your haircut, the way you dress and the way you walk and perceive yourself with confidence is not usual or normal for females here.. so, i started to watch women coming out of the TV building.. that is the closest working spot to my mum’s place... here is what i have realized.. apart from the hijab.. which is understandable and apart from the poor taste in colour combinations.. women walk in themselves.. very difficult to describe, but they walk as if they should hide.. they walk slowly.. regardless of the fact that many dress up so prudently and in wide clothes, they still want to hide... as if they feel they are not meant to be in the public sphere.. i am talking about working women not even housewives whose husbands might be intimidating them in order to make sure that they know that their role is to hide.. maybe that also explains why some women won’t have a problem to hide their faces.. this is part and parcel of the equation and the psychological build up of females in the society.. so, if you are walking in self confidence.. as we say open to the world without fear.. then you are not an Egyptian.. if you walk fast in a steady step and you don’t look lost .. then you are not one either.. this is really sad.. and i am not sure that any of the rhetoric coming from the books of Elbanna on women that found its way to school books now will assist at all to make the community accept women as members of the community and not the slaves of the community that have to hide and only serve... i.e. for women to just feel normal again as a human being!
Friday, June 21, 2013
Thursday, May 30, 2013
Nostalgia in the minds of Egyptians today
Nostalgia
All of us are nostalgic.. we get this feeling when we look back and believe that our past was better than our present.. we think that if times go back our lives will be better.. or if time has stopped.. that is fine.. but when we are all looking back to a miserable life and compare it to another miserable life .. then we prefer one misery to the other.. this is just pitiful.
After Mubarak, and due to the stage of political struggle and loss we are living in, Egyptians are nostalgic… some are nostalgic to monarchy times… to the so called democracy at the time, elegance and cosmopolitan cities in the country … others are nostalgic to nasser’s time and the sense of national pride that he represented, regardless of lack of liberties that we are calling for… others are nostalgic to sadat’s time and our friendship with the west and the end of wars… all this, regardless of how far i agree or disagree with the reasons behind such nostalgia, the surprise is .. that many are nostalgic to Mubarak’s time…
The latter is also normal… but in the sense of we knew our way.. it was chaotic.. but I knew how to maneuver …. But in the sense that Mubarak and his regime were patriotic.. or they cared about the people.. this is nonsense.. I can’t believe that people have such short memory to why the rebelled… yes.. may be we are not happy with the current government … or some of us are really scared for the life that we know and we are used to.. but to just think of Mubarak regime now as flawless or balanced.. or thinking that what is going on with the Dam issue is not the accumulation of bad policies for many many years… and the current government for a year now did nothing to resolve the issue! Yes.. it is from bad to worse.. but the first is not much better… some people who are in denial of the mistakes of the current system of governance are just focused on the mistakes of Mubarak.. and they forget the mistakes of the current government in place for a year now.. moreover, those who are against the current regime are putting all the blame on it and want to show the Mubarak and his regime were heroes .. no.. they were not heroes.. they caused what we are in with their bad policies.. again.. in reality what I see is.. no one cares about the people anymore… and that is part or should be the top priority of our national interests..
Once, in one of my classes… while trying not to be biased to my political views while discussing the eras of Nasser and Sadat.. I ended a class saying that as you can see, when we stopped war nobody cared about the people… that was a simple sum up to the change of course of action of the government when it comes to policies in the benefits of workers and peasants rather than business people…. One of my students picked that line and asked me for my explanation later…
So I reflected on it and I informed her, that when war was on.. yes there were no freedoms to the people… life was hard.. but when the presidents knew there is lack of sugar, tea or rice.. they made sure people have it… receiving the minimum of goods to sustain a household was a must.. the government thought it is its responsibility to ensure that people find their basic needs… whether out of care for the people or to ensure minimum unrest internally because they couldn’t afford any chaos internally while the country is already involved in external wars.. it doesn’t matter.. for the people .. the regular people.. who don’t give a damn about politics or economics or these complicated matters of politicians in cairo.. all what they care for is to find food, drink, health care, be able to find a job .. earn enough money to sustain the family.. that when it exists.. people are ok..and maybe happy and relaxed… so.. in reality.. laws that were protecting the workers and farmers started to change after the wars.. the attempt to waive subsidies over the bread also started after the peace treaty.. so.. at the end.. people are still aspiring for a leader that think of them.. a government that puts their needs as a top priority not political gains… hence, if the few of us were relaxed in the previous regime.. and if many people say we were better off.. not because it was good.. but it was slightly better than the unknown we are living in… some who are in their 20s didn’t know better… that is why their comparison is simply between what they know and the unknown… but it has nothing to do with their aspirations to a real better life…
So, in brief… it is sad when people now say Mubarak was this or that.. or the people that we all know that were corrupt administratively, politically or financially are becoming heroes today!! If we can’t prove their corruption because they were good in hiding papers or messing up with the files that doesn’t mean that they were not at least corrupt politically…. So .. let’s please cut the chase and stop praising the old regime…. The current is not much better.. but that previous one was not good either.
All of us are nostalgic.. we get this feeling when we look back and believe that our past was better than our present.. we think that if times go back our lives will be better.. or if time has stopped.. that is fine.. but when we are all looking back to a miserable life and compare it to another miserable life .. then we prefer one misery to the other.. this is just pitiful.
After Mubarak, and due to the stage of political struggle and loss we are living in, Egyptians are nostalgic… some are nostalgic to monarchy times… to the so called democracy at the time, elegance and cosmopolitan cities in the country … others are nostalgic to nasser’s time and the sense of national pride that he represented, regardless of lack of liberties that we are calling for… others are nostalgic to sadat’s time and our friendship with the west and the end of wars… all this, regardless of how far i agree or disagree with the reasons behind such nostalgia, the surprise is .. that many are nostalgic to Mubarak’s time…
The latter is also normal… but in the sense of we knew our way.. it was chaotic.. but I knew how to maneuver …. But in the sense that Mubarak and his regime were patriotic.. or they cared about the people.. this is nonsense.. I can’t believe that people have such short memory to why the rebelled… yes.. may be we are not happy with the current government … or some of us are really scared for the life that we know and we are used to.. but to just think of Mubarak regime now as flawless or balanced.. or thinking that what is going on with the Dam issue is not the accumulation of bad policies for many many years… and the current government for a year now did nothing to resolve the issue! Yes.. it is from bad to worse.. but the first is not much better… some people who are in denial of the mistakes of the current system of governance are just focused on the mistakes of Mubarak.. and they forget the mistakes of the current government in place for a year now.. moreover, those who are against the current regime are putting all the blame on it and want to show the Mubarak and his regime were heroes .. no.. they were not heroes.. they caused what we are in with their bad policies.. again.. in reality what I see is.. no one cares about the people anymore… and that is part or should be the top priority of our national interests..
Once, in one of my classes… while trying not to be biased to my political views while discussing the eras of Nasser and Sadat.. I ended a class saying that as you can see, when we stopped war nobody cared about the people… that was a simple sum up to the change of course of action of the government when it comes to policies in the benefits of workers and peasants rather than business people…. One of my students picked that line and asked me for my explanation later…
So I reflected on it and I informed her, that when war was on.. yes there were no freedoms to the people… life was hard.. but when the presidents knew there is lack of sugar, tea or rice.. they made sure people have it… receiving the minimum of goods to sustain a household was a must.. the government thought it is its responsibility to ensure that people find their basic needs… whether out of care for the people or to ensure minimum unrest internally because they couldn’t afford any chaos internally while the country is already involved in external wars.. it doesn’t matter.. for the people .. the regular people.. who don’t give a damn about politics or economics or these complicated matters of politicians in cairo.. all what they care for is to find food, drink, health care, be able to find a job .. earn enough money to sustain the family.. that when it exists.. people are ok..and maybe happy and relaxed… so.. in reality.. laws that were protecting the workers and farmers started to change after the wars.. the attempt to waive subsidies over the bread also started after the peace treaty.. so.. at the end.. people are still aspiring for a leader that think of them.. a government that puts their needs as a top priority not political gains… hence, if the few of us were relaxed in the previous regime.. and if many people say we were better off.. not because it was good.. but it was slightly better than the unknown we are living in… some who are in their 20s didn’t know better… that is why their comparison is simply between what they know and the unknown… but it has nothing to do with their aspirations to a real better life…
So, in brief… it is sad when people now say Mubarak was this or that.. or the people that we all know that were corrupt administratively, politically or financially are becoming heroes today!! If we can’t prove their corruption because they were good in hiding papers or messing up with the files that doesn’t mean that they were not at least corrupt politically…. So .. let’s please cut the chase and stop praising the old regime…. The current is not much better.. but that previous one was not good either.
Wednesday, May 1, 2013
The Shadow of a Man Documentary
Last night I went to the show of a documentary called “Del Ragel” which means the shadow of a man… it is meant as a reference to the Egyptian proverb the shadow of a man is better than the shadow of a wall…i.e. a women is better off with a shadow of a useless man rather than staying on her own behind a wall. The show was followed by a discussion with the director that came up with the idea of the documentary… and the venue was one of the liberal social political parties, newly born in Egypt after the revolution of January 2011.
Here are some reflections on the movie, the political parties work and the discussion that followed:
1. The movie with some of my reflections :
The movie showed 4 main characters and two or three secondary characters and an interesting example of a man who was just present in the movie as a shadow.
- The first character is of a lady in her 30s from beni mazar in upper Egypt, showing her daily life. The lady and the husband are technical high school graduates. She got engaged at the age of 15… later married with 4 kids. The husband has no work and just sitting around the house or with friends. She does all the house work, raise the kids, follow the education of the 3 that go to school, she raises ducks, chicken and sometimes goats and sheep. This is how she generates little income for the family to survive. She runs the household and the husband is just a shadow. One day she was sick and the little kid, the toddler. She had to continue with her daily activities otherwise the birds will suffer, the house will be dirty and her kids won’t find food when they get back from school. The husband was out all day, doing nothing. When he got back, she was asking him why he didn’t check on her and the sick kid all day, while she had still to work all day at home. His response was… what effort are you talking about? You do nothing. She was deeply hurt for the lack of appreciation and compassion… they started a little fight that ended up in a divorce. She left the house, went to her family’s and in less than 2 weeks she returned to hers again. What can she do with 4 kids away from the father? And of course, it is unheard of in such communities that a divorced woman with kids would live on her own… so her only choice will be getting back to her family’s… so in this case, the shadow of a man is better. It was clear from her story that the husband at the time of the engagement was so lovely and jolly… he used to pamper her and that have gone away after marriage. This lady had dreams to be a painter… her father wanted to send her to school to study and become a nurse but the husband, who was the fiancé at the time, refused. She married because she was dreaming of the wedding, the dress and the party. She didn’t know what lied ahead.
- The second character was a lady in her early 30s from Damietta. She runs a small business- a store for gifts- and she is not married. She mentioned how she was harassed by her grandfather and how she was scared to inform anyone about it. When she had the courage to inform her mother, the latter had beaten her. That was a turning point in her life. She decided to take matters in her own hands and to work on her financial independence as a first step or a crucial step in her efforts to take the lead in her life. She admitted that she is happier not married… she got engaged several times and she freaked out whenever she felt that the men are interested in her sexually. She is traumatized because of her grandfather harassment. Opposing to her peers, she was happy to break the engagements and she felt as if a weight has been lifted after getting rid of the men. She has admitted that her decisions are all self made, she had ups and downs but she corrects her decisions on her own. She is happier without any man in her life. It is very clear that this is one of the cases of incest that leaves a mark on the psyche of the girl without knowing how to get out from the psychological trauma. She herself doesn’t realize or doesn’t trust in a therapy to her case and she went for the choice of living without a man. If she has been treated from this trauma, the choice might have been healthier. This is also a reflection to another aspect in the society of the difficulties in relation to change in the male chauvinist attitude towards girls. For a girl to mention the hurdles that she suffered on the hands of a family member is breaking a taboo. So this girl was courageous enough to talk about it. She doesn’t realize that this might be part of the healing process.
- The third character was an old lady in her mid 70s. She comes from one of the populous areas in Cairo. She started by joking that she hates men and she mentioned that she married at an early age against her will. The day of marriage, she was not alone with the husband. Her mum insisted that 2 neighboring ladies should witness the act of breaking the virginity by the finger of the husband. So, they basically witness that she married as a virgin and he can’t claim otherwise later. This is crucial for most of the men in Egypt and for the girl’s family. It is looked upon as a matter of honour. This lady hated her life with the husband she married. She got pregnant right away and has a daughter. She couldn’t take such a life for long and she has decided to run away. She took her daughter and rented an apartment in a place where neither the man nor her family knew where she was. She started to work in homes but the end of this life was around the corner. Her husband and family were able to find her. She asked for a divorce and threatened the husband if he comes near her she will break his leg. Her family made a fuss and insisted that she moves at her parents’ place. It is inappropriate for a woman to stay on her own. Her mum was nagging that she should remarry. The outcome was she left the whole country. She left her daughter to her mother; she worked in the gulf and ended up working at an Egyptian family’s place in London. She never remarried. She was not interested in men anymore. She made enough money to provide her with a decent living and she laughs at what she has gone through in her life. In such a patriarchal dogmatic system, females have no place other than running away. In fact, they discover that getting into a relationship with men in the community is a lost cause. Those who are strong enough to break taboos and move on with their lives seeking their independence, they end up running away rather than go for the experience and think that one’s experience might be different. Sometimes, this is regarded as a myth. The fact remains that looking around to experiences of others make it very difficult for the individual to think that his or her experience will be different or better.
- The fourth character is a national leader. Shahenda mekled. She is brought in a non-discriminatory way. Men in her life were so progressive. Her father and her husband were supportive of the role of women in the society and they believed in equality. That assisted her to be where she is. This reflects how the community affects the role of females in empowering them and making them reach new strides.
- There were other three secondary characters that showed up in the shop at Damietta. Two of them were totally covered, including their faces. They were speaking about women roles in a very progressive manner, especially in politics and as a president. They were more progressive in their views than the owner of the shop. While the latter was more courageous to face the community and work on her financial independence to have a say in her life, the other two who wore the complete veil didn’t do that. When their husbands came to call for them, they left directly. One of them was joking that she has done everything in her capacity to be appealing to her husband, yet he went and married another woman. The outcome, we knew later from the director that she removed her face cover. She was wearing it to please her husband, so when he married another woman, she didn’t find a reason why she should remain in it. The third woman talked very little and her presence was not really felt in the movie.
2. The discussion with the director:
The director is very young and that was her first piece of work. I thought it was done brilliantly for someone who is not that experienced in shooting such movies. The men in the meeting were not criticizing what they have seen, but someone wanted to see an image of a progressive man next to those who are laid back. The logical response was, the progressive men are not part of the social problem. The social problem lies within those laid back and that is what is of concern to the problems the movie is exposing. Another philosophized the shots more than what it was meant to show. This showed richness in the movie. Some of the ladies in the political party focused their comments on the totally veiled women. They didn’t believe them. They couldn’t understand the dichotomy they live in behind their veils. They only saw the covered faces as a sign of laid back kind of thinking and any progressive ideas that they brought in the movie were just fake because they are doing the opposite in their lives. They failed to understand the contradictions in the community that these women live in.
3. Political parties with liberal perspectives:
As always, what I keep repeating because it is an individual observation about women working on women issues in Egypt. Simply, they don’t get it. Women in political parties that come from the upper classes in Egypt, who are well educated and had relatively privileged lives don’t understand in full the dilemmas of local Egyptian women. Again it is a sort of isolation from the real world. This was very clear during the debate when they talked about the veiled women. If they don’t understand their psyche, how can they succeed at ground level work? They couldn’t break the stereotype of a veiled woman is only closed minded and whatever she will say is just for the public consumption because she herself can’t change the fact that she is just a follower to her husband. She couldn’t break free and when she talks progressively, it means that she is a hypocrite and doesn’t mean it. I might have the same problem, in the first instance, but listening to them talking made me feel, they may bring up their daughters in a different manner than they were brought up. So, maybe this progression will show in the next generation. The social structure and the patriarchal system that is so strong in most of the country that leads to a massive deprivation of women rights. They are deprived of different chances and choices in their lives and not all of them are strong enough to rebel. Maybe it is time to people who want to work on the empowerment of women in the community to get down from their ivory towers and look around them to understand what women really want in this community and assist them in gaining their economic independence in order to have the right to choose what they want for their lives.
Here are some reflections on the movie, the political parties work and the discussion that followed:
1. The movie with some of my reflections :
The movie showed 4 main characters and two or three secondary characters and an interesting example of a man who was just present in the movie as a shadow.
- The first character is of a lady in her 30s from beni mazar in upper Egypt, showing her daily life. The lady and the husband are technical high school graduates. She got engaged at the age of 15… later married with 4 kids. The husband has no work and just sitting around the house or with friends. She does all the house work, raise the kids, follow the education of the 3 that go to school, she raises ducks, chicken and sometimes goats and sheep. This is how she generates little income for the family to survive. She runs the household and the husband is just a shadow. One day she was sick and the little kid, the toddler. She had to continue with her daily activities otherwise the birds will suffer, the house will be dirty and her kids won’t find food when they get back from school. The husband was out all day, doing nothing. When he got back, she was asking him why he didn’t check on her and the sick kid all day, while she had still to work all day at home. His response was… what effort are you talking about? You do nothing. She was deeply hurt for the lack of appreciation and compassion… they started a little fight that ended up in a divorce. She left the house, went to her family’s and in less than 2 weeks she returned to hers again. What can she do with 4 kids away from the father? And of course, it is unheard of in such communities that a divorced woman with kids would live on her own… so her only choice will be getting back to her family’s… so in this case, the shadow of a man is better. It was clear from her story that the husband at the time of the engagement was so lovely and jolly… he used to pamper her and that have gone away after marriage. This lady had dreams to be a painter… her father wanted to send her to school to study and become a nurse but the husband, who was the fiancé at the time, refused. She married because she was dreaming of the wedding, the dress and the party. She didn’t know what lied ahead.
- The second character was a lady in her early 30s from Damietta. She runs a small business- a store for gifts- and she is not married. She mentioned how she was harassed by her grandfather and how she was scared to inform anyone about it. When she had the courage to inform her mother, the latter had beaten her. That was a turning point in her life. She decided to take matters in her own hands and to work on her financial independence as a first step or a crucial step in her efforts to take the lead in her life. She admitted that she is happier not married… she got engaged several times and she freaked out whenever she felt that the men are interested in her sexually. She is traumatized because of her grandfather harassment. Opposing to her peers, she was happy to break the engagements and she felt as if a weight has been lifted after getting rid of the men. She has admitted that her decisions are all self made, she had ups and downs but she corrects her decisions on her own. She is happier without any man in her life. It is very clear that this is one of the cases of incest that leaves a mark on the psyche of the girl without knowing how to get out from the psychological trauma. She herself doesn’t realize or doesn’t trust in a therapy to her case and she went for the choice of living without a man. If she has been treated from this trauma, the choice might have been healthier. This is also a reflection to another aspect in the society of the difficulties in relation to change in the male chauvinist attitude towards girls. For a girl to mention the hurdles that she suffered on the hands of a family member is breaking a taboo. So this girl was courageous enough to talk about it. She doesn’t realize that this might be part of the healing process.
- The third character was an old lady in her mid 70s. She comes from one of the populous areas in Cairo. She started by joking that she hates men and she mentioned that she married at an early age against her will. The day of marriage, she was not alone with the husband. Her mum insisted that 2 neighboring ladies should witness the act of breaking the virginity by the finger of the husband. So, they basically witness that she married as a virgin and he can’t claim otherwise later. This is crucial for most of the men in Egypt and for the girl’s family. It is looked upon as a matter of honour. This lady hated her life with the husband she married. She got pregnant right away and has a daughter. She couldn’t take such a life for long and she has decided to run away. She took her daughter and rented an apartment in a place where neither the man nor her family knew where she was. She started to work in homes but the end of this life was around the corner. Her husband and family were able to find her. She asked for a divorce and threatened the husband if he comes near her she will break his leg. Her family made a fuss and insisted that she moves at her parents’ place. It is inappropriate for a woman to stay on her own. Her mum was nagging that she should remarry. The outcome was she left the whole country. She left her daughter to her mother; she worked in the gulf and ended up working at an Egyptian family’s place in London. She never remarried. She was not interested in men anymore. She made enough money to provide her with a decent living and she laughs at what she has gone through in her life. In such a patriarchal dogmatic system, females have no place other than running away. In fact, they discover that getting into a relationship with men in the community is a lost cause. Those who are strong enough to break taboos and move on with their lives seeking their independence, they end up running away rather than go for the experience and think that one’s experience might be different. Sometimes, this is regarded as a myth. The fact remains that looking around to experiences of others make it very difficult for the individual to think that his or her experience will be different or better.
- The fourth character is a national leader. Shahenda mekled. She is brought in a non-discriminatory way. Men in her life were so progressive. Her father and her husband were supportive of the role of women in the society and they believed in equality. That assisted her to be where she is. This reflects how the community affects the role of females in empowering them and making them reach new strides.
- There were other three secondary characters that showed up in the shop at Damietta. Two of them were totally covered, including their faces. They were speaking about women roles in a very progressive manner, especially in politics and as a president. They were more progressive in their views than the owner of the shop. While the latter was more courageous to face the community and work on her financial independence to have a say in her life, the other two who wore the complete veil didn’t do that. When their husbands came to call for them, they left directly. One of them was joking that she has done everything in her capacity to be appealing to her husband, yet he went and married another woman. The outcome, we knew later from the director that she removed her face cover. She was wearing it to please her husband, so when he married another woman, she didn’t find a reason why she should remain in it. The third woman talked very little and her presence was not really felt in the movie.
2. The discussion with the director:
The director is very young and that was her first piece of work. I thought it was done brilliantly for someone who is not that experienced in shooting such movies. The men in the meeting were not criticizing what they have seen, but someone wanted to see an image of a progressive man next to those who are laid back. The logical response was, the progressive men are not part of the social problem. The social problem lies within those laid back and that is what is of concern to the problems the movie is exposing. Another philosophized the shots more than what it was meant to show. This showed richness in the movie. Some of the ladies in the political party focused their comments on the totally veiled women. They didn’t believe them. They couldn’t understand the dichotomy they live in behind their veils. They only saw the covered faces as a sign of laid back kind of thinking and any progressive ideas that they brought in the movie were just fake because they are doing the opposite in their lives. They failed to understand the contradictions in the community that these women live in.
3. Political parties with liberal perspectives:
As always, what I keep repeating because it is an individual observation about women working on women issues in Egypt. Simply, they don’t get it. Women in political parties that come from the upper classes in Egypt, who are well educated and had relatively privileged lives don’t understand in full the dilemmas of local Egyptian women. Again it is a sort of isolation from the real world. This was very clear during the debate when they talked about the veiled women. If they don’t understand their psyche, how can they succeed at ground level work? They couldn’t break the stereotype of a veiled woman is only closed minded and whatever she will say is just for the public consumption because she herself can’t change the fact that she is just a follower to her husband. She couldn’t break free and when she talks progressively, it means that she is a hypocrite and doesn’t mean it. I might have the same problem, in the first instance, but listening to them talking made me feel, they may bring up their daughters in a different manner than they were brought up. So, maybe this progression will show in the next generation. The social structure and the patriarchal system that is so strong in most of the country that leads to a massive deprivation of women rights. They are deprived of different chances and choices in their lives and not all of them are strong enough to rebel. Maybe it is time to people who want to work on the empowerment of women in the community to get down from their ivory towers and look around them to understand what women really want in this community and assist them in gaining their economic independence in order to have the right to choose what they want for their lives.
Thursday, April 11, 2013
Relationships (1) Communication
Relationships are pretty easy yet complicated.. the human psyche is not easy to comprehend..our tempers change as quickly as the waves in the ocean.. but waves follow each other.. same like our words... when they follow each other without considering the implications we hurt those we love. for that reason, communication is the first step towards a healthy relationship.
i came to realize through they years that one of the main reasons that people have problems in relationships is the lack of communication or bad communication among the partners. amazing enough, that as much as men and women existed together since the dawn of history, it seems that each think and react as if they come from two different worlds.
in a conversation between a friend of mine and his daughter, later another with his wife dealing with the same topic, the issue was in relation to going out together and the agreement was they should call him, if not then he will make other plans, which he did. 10 times he repeated, "you didn't call, so this means you didn't want to go out". i assumed that the other party, repeating the same thing but you said we will go out today, so he repeated his answer again until he said, anyways, it is already very late now because it was close to 11 pm. while reflecting on this conversation, i was laughing. men take things at face value. the agreement was void since they didn't call. the mother and the girl reacted emotionally because they have felt deprived from the attention of the husband and the father as he promised they would go out that night. the issue of calling or not was a minor issue for them. they took it for granted that they will go out, hence, he had broken his promise for not showing up.
in another instance, another friend and his wife, both were complaining of each others attitudes. he claimed that she is neglecting him by concentrating on her career, while she was complaining that he doesn't do enough for the relationship and he is jealous of her success, therefore he is always trying to bring her down. talking to both, i realized that they have a major communication problem. both of them are fixated on their assumption of the attitude of the other, so anything that follows is always analyzed in the negative. like, if she is late for an hour at the office for finishing work, he would make a fuss out of it and consider it a clear sign of negligence. while she, at the same time, will consider this as hampering her career and success. this dilemma kept going on.. she had promised that she will try to keep up with the working hours in order to have more time for him, but of course, due to the work conditions sometimes it was impossible to keep up the promise and he had zero tolerance for any delay, so the bickering continued and he was always on her case. so, she ended up treating him as an enemy... if he says the least of things she will always say, ah you don't want me to succeed and you just want me a house wife and a follower. in many instances, while talking to them, i have realized that, beside the other problems they have, communication is one of the major issues they fail to handle and it causes them lots of misery.
to be continued...
i came to realize through they years that one of the main reasons that people have problems in relationships is the lack of communication or bad communication among the partners. amazing enough, that as much as men and women existed together since the dawn of history, it seems that each think and react as if they come from two different worlds.
in a conversation between a friend of mine and his daughter, later another with his wife dealing with the same topic, the issue was in relation to going out together and the agreement was they should call him, if not then he will make other plans, which he did. 10 times he repeated, "you didn't call, so this means you didn't want to go out". i assumed that the other party, repeating the same thing but you said we will go out today, so he repeated his answer again until he said, anyways, it is already very late now because it was close to 11 pm. while reflecting on this conversation, i was laughing. men take things at face value. the agreement was void since they didn't call. the mother and the girl reacted emotionally because they have felt deprived from the attention of the husband and the father as he promised they would go out that night. the issue of calling or not was a minor issue for them. they took it for granted that they will go out, hence, he had broken his promise for not showing up.
in another instance, another friend and his wife, both were complaining of each others attitudes. he claimed that she is neglecting him by concentrating on her career, while she was complaining that he doesn't do enough for the relationship and he is jealous of her success, therefore he is always trying to bring her down. talking to both, i realized that they have a major communication problem. both of them are fixated on their assumption of the attitude of the other, so anything that follows is always analyzed in the negative. like, if she is late for an hour at the office for finishing work, he would make a fuss out of it and consider it a clear sign of negligence. while she, at the same time, will consider this as hampering her career and success. this dilemma kept going on.. she had promised that she will try to keep up with the working hours in order to have more time for him, but of course, due to the work conditions sometimes it was impossible to keep up the promise and he had zero tolerance for any delay, so the bickering continued and he was always on her case. so, she ended up treating him as an enemy... if he says the least of things she will always say, ah you don't want me to succeed and you just want me a house wife and a follower. in many instances, while talking to them, i have realized that, beside the other problems they have, communication is one of the major issues they fail to handle and it causes them lots of misery.
to be continued...
Tuesday, March 26, 2013
Real Life Stories from Egypt (2)
poverty and health... two things that do not mix..
two stories from real life, of course there are many more, but those are the recent ones that i go to know.
the first is in the country side, one of the peasants was telling my mum; how she has been suffering from constant headaches and she doesn't feel well.. so, the first question my mum asked her if she has checked her blood pressure??? she responded that she has never done it... so my mum offered her to go to the pharmacy to check it on mum's account...and after asking her some questions about frequency of peeing, feeling thirsty all the time and other few things, my mum told her that she has to check the level of the sugar in her blood. so the husband of the lady said.. oh no, she suffers from high level of minerals in the body, hence the idea of diabetes is ruled out.. A MYTH of course.. so anyways.. my mum sent her to check both, and they found out that she had diabetes! the poor lady had a sweet tooth and she loves sweets.. so she has been living her life without any clue why she was not feeling well.
i asked my mum, why didn't she go and check in the local clinic.. i know that they had a local health unit in the village that was government run and for free.. so my mum responded that is the main problem, the unit is not working anymore and these poor people don't have any healthcare.. and they can't afford going to the centre of the governorate to a private clinic to get real health care.. it felt so bad to know that in one of the most developed governorates in the delta, this is what the people have to face when they get sick...
the other story is related to a taxi driver, who is of course struggling to make a living and his wife is a cleaning lady found out that he has to undergo cataract operation for his eyes. before, when rules were lax, he could pay few hundred pounds and renew his driver's license.. but now, the attempt failed and in order to get his license back he has to undergo the operation. they are afraid to go anywhere for the operation.. it is the eyes after all.. if he loses his sight.. he loses everything.. so, the outcome, with the assistance of a nurse .. one of their family members .. a Dr. checked his condition and told him that he has to buy the lens, which will cost nearly 3000 pounds and around 3000 more for the hospital and administrative fees. the oculist confirmed that he will perform the operation for free.
how would a poor family struggling to survive pay 6000 pounds? how long will it take them to save such money? when we had free health care, it was poor but at least many of the people were able to receive any health care.. we inherited a rotten system from the previous era which totally disregarded the poor and the deprived... so where are we now? the current house of the parliament is only concerned about the political process to consolidate power, the ministry of finance is squeezing the rich and the poor by lifting subsidies and increasing taxes.. and the president is roaming around the globe on the account of the tax payers.. i.e. the citizens again... what is left? why no one is paying any attention to the problems of the poor people in this country? is it normal that a government in place after an uprising for social justice work again in an isolated island of its own and not paying attention to anything that is taking place in the country?
if you talk to any of those individuals, why would they care about democracy? or about what is going on with regard to political struggles between those elites who reside in cairo and come out to talk to us in suits? would they care if x or y is in power? if their conditions is deteriorating and no one is paying attention to them.. why would they pay attention to us when we ask them to go vote and to whom will they vote for.. for them .. all are the same.. their lives are the same.. their poverty level is the same and their health will keep deteriorating!
two stories from real life, of course there are many more, but those are the recent ones that i go to know.
the first is in the country side, one of the peasants was telling my mum; how she has been suffering from constant headaches and she doesn't feel well.. so, the first question my mum asked her if she has checked her blood pressure??? she responded that she has never done it... so my mum offered her to go to the pharmacy to check it on mum's account...and after asking her some questions about frequency of peeing, feeling thirsty all the time and other few things, my mum told her that she has to check the level of the sugar in her blood. so the husband of the lady said.. oh no, she suffers from high level of minerals in the body, hence the idea of diabetes is ruled out.. A MYTH of course.. so anyways.. my mum sent her to check both, and they found out that she had diabetes! the poor lady had a sweet tooth and she loves sweets.. so she has been living her life without any clue why she was not feeling well.
i asked my mum, why didn't she go and check in the local clinic.. i know that they had a local health unit in the village that was government run and for free.. so my mum responded that is the main problem, the unit is not working anymore and these poor people don't have any healthcare.. and they can't afford going to the centre of the governorate to a private clinic to get real health care.. it felt so bad to know that in one of the most developed governorates in the delta, this is what the people have to face when they get sick...
the other story is related to a taxi driver, who is of course struggling to make a living and his wife is a cleaning lady found out that he has to undergo cataract operation for his eyes. before, when rules were lax, he could pay few hundred pounds and renew his driver's license.. but now, the attempt failed and in order to get his license back he has to undergo the operation. they are afraid to go anywhere for the operation.. it is the eyes after all.. if he loses his sight.. he loses everything.. so, the outcome, with the assistance of a nurse .. one of their family members .. a Dr. checked his condition and told him that he has to buy the lens, which will cost nearly 3000 pounds and around 3000 more for the hospital and administrative fees. the oculist confirmed that he will perform the operation for free.
how would a poor family struggling to survive pay 6000 pounds? how long will it take them to save such money? when we had free health care, it was poor but at least many of the people were able to receive any health care.. we inherited a rotten system from the previous era which totally disregarded the poor and the deprived... so where are we now? the current house of the parliament is only concerned about the political process to consolidate power, the ministry of finance is squeezing the rich and the poor by lifting subsidies and increasing taxes.. and the president is roaming around the globe on the account of the tax payers.. i.e. the citizens again... what is left? why no one is paying any attention to the problems of the poor people in this country? is it normal that a government in place after an uprising for social justice work again in an isolated island of its own and not paying attention to anything that is taking place in the country?
if you talk to any of those individuals, why would they care about democracy? or about what is going on with regard to political struggles between those elites who reside in cairo and come out to talk to us in suits? would they care if x or y is in power? if their conditions is deteriorating and no one is paying attention to them.. why would they pay attention to us when we ask them to go vote and to whom will they vote for.. for them .. all are the same.. their lives are the same.. their poverty level is the same and their health will keep deteriorating!
Friday, March 22, 2013
Real Life Stories from Egypt (1)
This part of the blog will be dedicated to stories about the Egyptian community and relations from real life.
A puzzling story was narrated to me last night, as I am interested in writing about relationships in the Egyptian community… a rich divorced lady met a police administrator who is way younger than her. She liked him, so she proposed to marry him. The guy told her that he is married with kids and he can’t afford being with her. He barely makes it through the month.
She offered him to support him and his family. He went to his wife, the mother of his kids, and told her about the offer. She was ok with it. She told him that it is ok for him to marry the other woman as long as they are getting support out of it.
The rich lady got the family an apartment not far from where she lives in order to make it convenient to the new husband to be between both. She got him a café to run and benefit financially from the revenues. Today, the rich wife visits the poorer one and brings presents to his kids. This is the situation until I wrote these lines.
Doesn’t this story tell a lot about interests in the society? Marriage became a market for supply and demand… the rich lady wanted a man for sex and company without strict marital obligations. Hence, she bought that. She put on the pants, she proposed, paid for the marriage and she is the one on top of the relationship. She pays, she orders. She gets all what she wants done by a husband ... the dream of every woman, assistant, love, compassion, companionship… the whole package because she paid for it.
The man is benefiting in this case, he gets laid, sleeping with a woman he might have not dared to dream to be with, and he became richer. He is able to support his old family without problems. He has accepted slavery to a rich woman and in return his life became easier. But, where that leaves him as MAN? Where will his dignity be? Where is his self respect? How will he face his children when they grow older? What kind of ethics will he teach them?
As for the old wife, she didn’t care about emotions rather than material factors. This is very practical solution for her problems. She doesn’t love her husband, otherwise, she might have had problems in accepting the fact that he will be going with another woman. Also, circumcision might be one of the reasons that if he is going to sleep with another woman, hence, he won’t bother her that frequent to have sex with her where she gets no pleasure whatsoever. For her, this was a business proposal, so she didn’t react emotionally to it but making a fuss how her husband is going to marry another woman, but she weighed the matter. The pros and cons and she had found out, if he goes and marry the woman without her approval, he may abandon her and the kids. Hence, it might be worth it to accept the fact that her husband will have another wife but she will benefit out of it. Now, she lives comfortably and has her material demands met rather than being deprived of life.
The question is; are they happy? Where are the moral values to be taught to the coming generations from such stories? How did the institution of marriage become a product subject to demand and supply theory? What kind of emasculated men this society ended up with? Are the social, economic or psychological factors the reason for sucking dignity and self esteem from Egyptian men?
This is an example of one social/family issue that I intend to write about and try to answer the questions; why and how did we reach this level of value corruption in Egypt?
A puzzling story was narrated to me last night, as I am interested in writing about relationships in the Egyptian community… a rich divorced lady met a police administrator who is way younger than her. She liked him, so she proposed to marry him. The guy told her that he is married with kids and he can’t afford being with her. He barely makes it through the month.
She offered him to support him and his family. He went to his wife, the mother of his kids, and told her about the offer. She was ok with it. She told him that it is ok for him to marry the other woman as long as they are getting support out of it.
The rich lady got the family an apartment not far from where she lives in order to make it convenient to the new husband to be between both. She got him a café to run and benefit financially from the revenues. Today, the rich wife visits the poorer one and brings presents to his kids. This is the situation until I wrote these lines.
Doesn’t this story tell a lot about interests in the society? Marriage became a market for supply and demand… the rich lady wanted a man for sex and company without strict marital obligations. Hence, she bought that. She put on the pants, she proposed, paid for the marriage and she is the one on top of the relationship. She pays, she orders. She gets all what she wants done by a husband ... the dream of every woman, assistant, love, compassion, companionship… the whole package because she paid for it.
The man is benefiting in this case, he gets laid, sleeping with a woman he might have not dared to dream to be with, and he became richer. He is able to support his old family without problems. He has accepted slavery to a rich woman and in return his life became easier. But, where that leaves him as MAN? Where will his dignity be? Where is his self respect? How will he face his children when they grow older? What kind of ethics will he teach them?
As for the old wife, she didn’t care about emotions rather than material factors. This is very practical solution for her problems. She doesn’t love her husband, otherwise, she might have had problems in accepting the fact that he will be going with another woman. Also, circumcision might be one of the reasons that if he is going to sleep with another woman, hence, he won’t bother her that frequent to have sex with her where she gets no pleasure whatsoever. For her, this was a business proposal, so she didn’t react emotionally to it but making a fuss how her husband is going to marry another woman, but she weighed the matter. The pros and cons and she had found out, if he goes and marry the woman without her approval, he may abandon her and the kids. Hence, it might be worth it to accept the fact that her husband will have another wife but she will benefit out of it. Now, she lives comfortably and has her material demands met rather than being deprived of life.
The question is; are they happy? Where are the moral values to be taught to the coming generations from such stories? How did the institution of marriage become a product subject to demand and supply theory? What kind of emasculated men this society ended up with? Are the social, economic or psychological factors the reason for sucking dignity and self esteem from Egyptian men?
This is an example of one social/family issue that I intend to write about and try to answer the questions; why and how did we reach this level of value corruption in Egypt?
Friday, October 12, 2012
a new phase in the power struggle in Egypt
the latest news about removing the PUblic Prosecutor from his office against the law and posting him as ambassador to Egypt to the Vatican is alarming on so many different levels and exposes the lack of respect to the rule of law even more than the previous regime...
first, the removal of the Public Prosecutor from office:
1. the public prosecutor post in Egypt is part of it's judiciary and in accordance with the law, he is appointed by the president upon the nomination by the supreme council for judiciary. no one, even the president, has the power to remove him from his post. either, he resigns, retires or dies.
2. the president decided, in accordance with the news, to remove the Prosecutor to another post, which is ambassador. this step was meant to overcome the difficulty of banning the total removal from the post by law by moving him to another governmental post.
3. this step is considered clear encroachment by the executive power on the judiciary power as enshrined in the constitutional declaration.
4. moreover, this encroachment entails the lack of rule of law and the respect to the laws of the country by the highest authority of the executive power, the President.
ambassadorial appointments:
1. form sometime now there was a systematic attack on the ministry of foreign affairs, it's budget and any privileges it's officials receive. some may think this is done haphazard by some politicians or journalists. however, I believe that this attack is launched very prudently. the purpose is very clear, this institution is in need of invasion by the new power that overtook the presidency, the MB.
2. the appointment of ousted officials as ambassadors is just a start, this is in preparation to appointing more ambassadors from outside the career diplomats. the rumours about a list of 100 individuals sent to MFA to be appointed as ambassadors, if proven true, will also be a breach to the law. in accordance with the law of the diplomatic corps of Egypt, the president has the right to nominate only 10% political appointees from outside the diplomatic corps as ambassadors. egypt has 163 missions around the globe, 100 is definitely way more than the 10%... unless the president with his legislative powers amends the law!!
3. the way the presidency regards the MFA is alarming, it is no different than the previous regime, poche, snob White collared diplomats are not of use.. they are not regarded as proper officials with expertise to be useful or professionals that can work with any political regime. this is a very serious shift, from a regime that trusted no other than security officials, to another that disregards the fact that diplomats, in Egypt, by their build up, are trained to serve the country under the command of any political power and not to align themselves to any specific faction or political party by law. yet, the move towards undermining the work of career diplomats for the sake of specific political agenda is alarming and appointing unwanted officials as ambassadors shows that the presidency doesn't regard their work of any value.
4. it's an international insult to get rid of officials and send them as ambassadors, it is true that this takes place a lot in third world countries, but that is why some of these countries are never taken serious.
third: struggle for power:
the MB is hammering hard in order to consolidate it's power and grip over the country and it's institutions. they were able to get rid of SCAF members that opposed to their absolute power. they managed to change the cabinet of ministers In a way to serve their interests rather than the country's interest. the last step that has been taken now, the close grip on the judiciary and the MFA.
the removal of the Public Prosecutor in the aftermath of a court decision that he had nothing to do with, because the preparation of that case wasn't done in his office but independenty by an investigative judge, is another phase in submitting the judiciary to the power of the presidency and make sure that the decisions will be more in line with the policies of the group that occupies power at this stage. this is a long awaited and expected step after the decision to dissolve the parliament... one step after the other, all the authorities of the government will be submitting to one political faction's powers.
the people of the country at this stage are lost between such struggle for power and don't know who to support... what many don't recognise that the lack of rule of law and due process will bring us back hundreds of years instead of pulling us forward from the situation we are in. people don't realise that without rule of law, there won't be investments, with no investments there won't be development, without development the country's problems will escalate further and one wonders until when people won't realise that business oriented ruling won't differ under any ideology or pretence and that their lives will still be miserable be it engineered by EZ or Shater.
first, the removal of the Public Prosecutor from office:
1. the public prosecutor post in Egypt is part of it's judiciary and in accordance with the law, he is appointed by the president upon the nomination by the supreme council for judiciary. no one, even the president, has the power to remove him from his post. either, he resigns, retires or dies.
2. the president decided, in accordance with the news, to remove the Prosecutor to another post, which is ambassador. this step was meant to overcome the difficulty of banning the total removal from the post by law by moving him to another governmental post.
3. this step is considered clear encroachment by the executive power on the judiciary power as enshrined in the constitutional declaration.
4. moreover, this encroachment entails the lack of rule of law and the respect to the laws of the country by the highest authority of the executive power, the President.
ambassadorial appointments:
1. form sometime now there was a systematic attack on the ministry of foreign affairs, it's budget and any privileges it's officials receive. some may think this is done haphazard by some politicians or journalists. however, I believe that this attack is launched very prudently. the purpose is very clear, this institution is in need of invasion by the new power that overtook the presidency, the MB.
2. the appointment of ousted officials as ambassadors is just a start, this is in preparation to appointing more ambassadors from outside the career diplomats. the rumours about a list of 100 individuals sent to MFA to be appointed as ambassadors, if proven true, will also be a breach to the law. in accordance with the law of the diplomatic corps of Egypt, the president has the right to nominate only 10% political appointees from outside the diplomatic corps as ambassadors. egypt has 163 missions around the globe, 100 is definitely way more than the 10%... unless the president with his legislative powers amends the law!!
3. the way the presidency regards the MFA is alarming, it is no different than the previous regime, poche, snob White collared diplomats are not of use.. they are not regarded as proper officials with expertise to be useful or professionals that can work with any political regime. this is a very serious shift, from a regime that trusted no other than security officials, to another that disregards the fact that diplomats, in Egypt, by their build up, are trained to serve the country under the command of any political power and not to align themselves to any specific faction or political party by law. yet, the move towards undermining the work of career diplomats for the sake of specific political agenda is alarming and appointing unwanted officials as ambassadors shows that the presidency doesn't regard their work of any value.
4. it's an international insult to get rid of officials and send them as ambassadors, it is true that this takes place a lot in third world countries, but that is why some of these countries are never taken serious.
third: struggle for power:
the MB is hammering hard in order to consolidate it's power and grip over the country and it's institutions. they were able to get rid of SCAF members that opposed to their absolute power. they managed to change the cabinet of ministers In a way to serve their interests rather than the country's interest. the last step that has been taken now, the close grip on the judiciary and the MFA.
the removal of the Public Prosecutor in the aftermath of a court decision that he had nothing to do with, because the preparation of that case wasn't done in his office but independenty by an investigative judge, is another phase in submitting the judiciary to the power of the presidency and make sure that the decisions will be more in line with the policies of the group that occupies power at this stage. this is a long awaited and expected step after the decision to dissolve the parliament... one step after the other, all the authorities of the government will be submitting to one political faction's powers.
the people of the country at this stage are lost between such struggle for power and don't know who to support... what many don't recognise that the lack of rule of law and due process will bring us back hundreds of years instead of pulling us forward from the situation we are in. people don't realise that without rule of law, there won't be investments, with no investments there won't be development, without development the country's problems will escalate further and one wonders until when people won't realise that business oriented ruling won't differ under any ideology or pretence and that their lives will still be miserable be it engineered by EZ or Shater.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)