Monday, January 9, 2012

Japan ... an experience of a lifetime! (1) The Tokyo Experience

as it may be figured out from the title.. japan a land of many wonders.. strange for our part of the world.. distant and our main aquaintance with the Japanese outside Japan is linked to strange language, habbits and richness... the experience in japan is such an enlightenment to the japanese history, habits and culture.

Mind you before you read what i will write.. these are personal reflections not based on research or thorough understanding of this great nation.. it is the outcome of visiting few places in Japan and it is yet to be updated after further trips in the country.

just for those who don't know...i comment a lot on bowing, because i don't bow except for god.. in our culture bowing is an expression of being submissive and in the old days before islam.. this was only done by slaves not the nobles or the free people.. so, when islam came... the ones who joined islam.. even if they were slaves stopped bowing except in prayers... as a sign of submissiveness to god and that we only bow to Him. it makes me really humble when i see the japanese people bow in their greetings..


first impression when landing in Osaka on my way to Tokyo:


1. organization is impressive.

2. failure to comprehend why do people in short transit coming from abroad have to disembark, go into the airport to pass a security check (not passport control) then back to board the same plane to Tokyo.

3. cleanliness is amazing.

4. leaving Osaka to Tokyo, while in the plane.. the ground service guys were waving "bye wave" and bowing to the plane and the people inside it.. this is a plane leaving for less than 1 hour flight between Osaka and Tokyo .. yet the cheer was astonishing for me. Didn't see that anywhere i have been to.

second.. Tokyo or Eastern Capital :

according to wikepedia, Tokyo was originally known as Edo, meaning "estuary". Its name was changed to Tokyo (Tōkyō: tō (east) + kyō (capital)) when it became the imperial capital in 1868, in line with the East Asian tradition of including the word capital ('京') in the name of the capital city. During the early Meiji period, the city was also called "Tōkei", an alternative pronunciation for the same Chinese characters representing "Tokyo". Some surviving official English documents use the spelling "Tokei". However, this pronunciation is now obsolete.

1. arrived in Tokyo at night after a very long flight.. with a jetlag.. made it difficult to figure out the feature or the character of anything around.

2. the Bus from Narita Airport to Tokyo.. was clean.. people are obligated to use seat belts.. it is not a choice.. people queued patiently and on the same spot several busses going to different destinations pick up their passengers.. the waiting spot by the station is categorized like a table...1, 2 and 3 to identify that passengers that will mount the first arriving bus should queue in 1 and so on..
anyone in the service answers your question with a bow..

3. Tokyo city... i tried to figure out what are the similarities and differences between it and cities i have visited before.. i wanted to get down to whether Tokyo is like Bangkok but cleaner and more organized or the Asian version of New York? so far it is way more Asian to be New York and maybe that is why it might be closer to bangkok.. i only compare to the later because it is the sole capital I have visited in East Asia..

The City is very clean... for it's size, busy streets with cars and construction.. it is very quiet city... i am the only noisy one in the street... even those who are drunk they don't make such loud noise.. in cafes, restaurants, bars or trains people are not loud.. they respect the others and they make sure that their noise is not annoying people around them.

as a foreigner, you are so easily to be identified and sometimes you can be subject to suspicion or amusement.. our moves are different, looks, shape, colour... everything... so you will always be subject to a second look out of curiosity.. but not necessarily a stare...

the trains and underground are clean... people stay in their coats even if they have a long trip in the train and it is pretty warm... the only trains i have even been into in the north where they have the heaters below the seats.. yes.. they do :)which makes the seat pretty warm :).. it doesn't get as cold as NY or Canada.. yet they warm your seat :)pretty nice .. huh :) of course, i had a sense some stared at me when i took off 2 layers of my clothes to end up in a Tshirt because it seems crazy for them and i guess they always try to figure out where one is from.. but they never ask :)

people are very neately dressed... always carrying a bag.. men and women.. no one goes around without a briefcase, carrying bags.. big handbags.. it is a must here.. they don't like to carry papers or anything outside of their bags..some get small pocket books to read.. with small japanese kanji.. katakana or hiragana.. i can't tell of course.. it looks like riddles to a japanese illiterate like me :) also, they like cute small things.. they love to hang things in their phones and bags.. it is not a female thing.. or childish.. all of them.. one barely sees a mobile phones without cords with zillion little things hanging out of it.. dolls, balls, comic images.. anything.. but it won't jut be empty.

the TOKYO TOWER:

another experience, the Tokyo Tower was built as a symbol of pride and resistance .. i believe this whole nation is a symbol of both.. everything was so organized in the Tower.. again very clean ..it is like a replica of the Tour Eiffel.. but with the colours of Japan's flag. again, anyone answers your politely and they take your ticket .. allow you to get into the lift with a bow..

the view is close to that from the Roppongi Hill Club Restaurant which overlooks a big part of the city but the nice thing int he Tower that you can see all angles and they show you how many kilometers each famous city is far from the Tower.. like Yokohama was 25 Km.. etc

Exchanging money in a bank:

i am considered as a relatively polite person.. i don't like swearing or scolding.. and i greet people with a smile.. i got a shock to the level of greeting one gets in a japanese bank!

i went down to change currency.. the first one to meet in the bank is the info individual.. i asked .. i want to change dollars to yen.. i got a bow, a smile, a ticket and directions in japanese with hand gestures for me to understand where i should wait and for which teller.

very clean and organized surrounding.. waiting and watching people.. and now my number buzzed. .went to the desk with two chairs where i will sit with the teller/ customer service like individual to change my money.. i said hi.. i want to change dollars to yen.. she smiled and bowed before saying anything.. i had to sit so she can sit.. then we started the procedure.. you can see it is bureaucratic but it goes smooth and all the procedures take very short time.. after finishing the process.. she gives back the receipt.. the money and an enveloppe in a plastic plate.. anywhere you will have a plate to use to put your money and to get your change.. be it a shop or the bank..

when she was done ... i was still getting my stuff into my bag.. she stood up to greet me .. and she bowed like 2 or 3 times until i left her desk...

i am sure the japanese have very flexible back muscles :) but the signs of politeness in the greetings in anything official put anyone into humbleness..


Streets of Tokyo:

the size of the streets in Tokyo are strange.. they've a highway in the middle of the city... and some streets are more like alleys.. pretty small and the pavement is just a line on the ground to separate cars from pedisterians.. however, again it is sooo organized.. the small streets are all having mirrors installed inorder for the drivers to see who's coming from where... because these tiny streets are full of intersections...these streets are also two way streets while their width can only pass one car.. hence, the cars coming from opposite directions wait until the cars that are entering the street pass..

if you are a pedisterian and waited for a car to pass while standing by the crossing lines.. the driver will bow to you as a sign of gratitude..

they drive on the right side like the UK... pretty confusing.. but i drove last night on the highway.. for a change i had to abide by the speed limit being it the first time i drive on the opposite side of the street.. but except for few exceptions.. the drivers stick to their lanes in traffic jams.. again things are pretty organized and signs are everywhere... so it is fitting with everything in the City.

the Sushi bar in the Fish Market:


in my first days in Tokyo, Ragui took me and Mai to a Sushi bar in the fish market area for dinner... it was almost closing time for fish shops.. but i managed to take a glimpse of how it is.. again, cleaner than most of the fish markets i have been to... i have seen a head of a fish bigger than the head of a cow or almost the same size and i have seen the huge pacific ocean crab that is kep alive in ice cubes..

the sushi bar is not different than those abroad, like the one in harvey and nichols in sloan street in london.. yet, the fish was very fresh and i have found out that you prepare your own green tea.. they leave the tea in a pot with an amazing tiny spoon.. we had cups to use for the tea and a tab that brings out boiling water every 2 or 3 persons... it was strange, different and yet practical way to serve oneself. wasabi is not served automatic here, unlike sushi places outside japan... you have to ask for it but the ginger slices are left in a box next to the green tea and the chopsticks for the customers.

they use different plate colours to identify the difference in prices for whatever you pick... then when it is time to depart, they come and count the plates from each colour and make the calculation for the customers... you don't pay the waiters but you pay at the counter.

Meeting freinds in Japan:

one of the very nice things in this trip as always is the reunion with friends and catching up after a long time.. the first one i met was one of my Finnish friends who is now married to a diplomat from New Zealand and posted in Japan.. it was very nice to meet up for dinner .. but unfortunately, time was so tight to see her 2 little ones this trip.. hopefully next time we meet we will have more time together...

the other reunion was meeting 2 japanese diplomats whom i used to work with in NY.. we had lunch in a traditional japanese restaurant.. it was so nice.. the restaurant experience was new for me and it was also nice to catch up with them and see how things are...it was so funny that somethings i have noticed, they never thought of.. i guess when one is an outsider.. one sees things different than those in the place.. it is the same when people come and comment about us and they appreciate things or have a critical view to things that we don't notice at all...but i believe this is the nature of things..


New Year's Eve a la Japanese in Meiju Jingu Temple:



Instead of going again to Asakusa Temple for new year’s eve, Mai and I went to Meiji Jingu Shrine, which seems to be one of the most popular destinations for Japanese that night. The walk from omotesando to the beginning of the shrine was long, but I didn’t realize that the walk in the woods to the holy site is longer and in stony ground…

The pathway towards the shrine took almost 2 hours or more because it was packed. People were standing patiently and there was no real pushing or attempts to take over your spot… the maximum was few people would push you a bit when the walking gets to a halt or try to take you over from the sides without hitting you if possible. It was as if they were queuing… in the middle of the pathway, we had a big screen that broadcasted live the rituals in the temple.

Finally, at the end of the walk we reached a point where we were relatively crushed with people trying to throw their coins and make their wishes for the new year… the bar that was installed in order to prevent people from reaching the wide spot in front of the temple where the coins were thrown was about to fall… the security guards rushed to save it by their own bodies and they managed until we left that spot.

I wanted to go into the temple to band the drums, but the entrance fee was between 10 to 30 thousand yen… so I thought that is pretty expensive so I refrained from going in.

Later, I have discovered that people in Japan all through January they go to the shrines and temples in order to make their wishes for the New Year… many consider it more of tradition rather than religion. My guide in Nara told me that it is preferable for this trip to dress up formally or in their traditional kimonos. It is one of the occasions that Kimonos are worn at ease as a celebratory uniform or like feast new clothes for us.

That was my Japanese New Year’s Eve experience. Different I would say than our normal parties whether dancing parties or traditional gatherings in that night.

Kamakura Temples:


Kamakura is a small town, not far from Tokyo… very traditional whenever you get closer to the temples… the temples we visited that day were Buddhist temples… although it is very hard to make a full distinction in Japan between Buddhism, Shinto or Hindu deities. They mix all together and they consider them all as gods, each with a specific power except for Buddha who is the head master of all. It reminded me with Zeus and the Greek gods and goddesses or the Pharaoh deities from Atun, Raa, Horus, Isis or Osiris…

The day we visited, the temples were packed… it was during the national holiday in Japan and people were going to the temples for getting their blessings and making their new year’s wishes.

At the temples, people stand with great respect and humbleness… they bow, they clap their hands and then hold them together like in the Christian prayers. They later buy from Monks wishes or slogans of protection on small pieces of paper and they hang them to little wires that have been installed at the exit of the temples for that purpose.. but I got to understand from Mai that originally they should be hanged on trees but these wires were made as a substitute to enable the big numbers to hang their wishes as close as possible to both the temples and the trees.
In Kamakura, we found sweet potatoes like ours in Egypt. Mai and I were so excited and we had very nice roasted sweet potatoes that were really sweet. We also visited an old store where they had hand painted lacquer and Japanese style porcelain and crystals… it was nice to see the fine little cravings they had on many of the items… which was wildly expensive as well… it was good for watching but not buying :)

One more experience in Tokyo was the Metropolitan Museum which included the biggest collection of Japanese art crafts including pottery, samurai swords, deities and others from different eras of the Japanese history, the Edo, Nara and other periods.
The Museum is located in Ueno Park so close to the Ueno Zoo and in a complex of different museums including the nature and science museum and the western art museum… but unfortunately, my knee problem didn’t allow me except going for the first museum and couldn’t do more that day.

One evening we went to the Ueno area Mai and her friend Chiho for shopping… it was a different style of shopping in comparison to the other parts of Tokyo. It doesn’t have the lavish shops as Ginza or omotesando, yet brands were sold together with many handmade silver and leather products designed by the shop owners themselves. I managed to buy some shiseido products for relatively ok prices which are quiet expensive everywhere in the world, even in Japan. The place also had a big fish market place where fresh and dried fish were sold. I still hated the smell, but it is still not to be compared with our fish market or the fish market that I have visited in Thailand… in both I won’t last for 2 minutes because I can’t stand the smell… still here it was not nice but I was able to stand it for a change.

Akihabara and the electronics:

no one should laugh at this.. this reminded me with abd Elaziz Street in Cairo.. where you have zillion shops selling all kinds of electronics.. except that here.. electronics are the top notch thing .. so from selling used electronics to the latest models that have just been released are here... i spent almost a day here... electronic addicts shouldn't miss that spot.. it is still expensive.. we are in Japan.. but it is worth taking a look at least :)


Kabukicho experience:


This is supposed to be the notorious part of the city… the place where the Japanese Mafia is active, escort services and different shows take place here. Display of nudity is forbidden in Japan and prostitution is illegal… that is why, in comparison to Soho in London or the Red Light District in Amsterdam or Antwerpen... there was nothing to see on display… there were only people standing out trying to talk to the pedestrians to step in. the shops charge by the hour, hence you would be provided with a table and you can order drinks, snacks and men/women escorts would come to join your table to entertain you.. depending on the place… there were many gay spots “gentlemen clubs” where gay guys will get nice looking guys to join them… at the entrance of these shops, you would find gay guys standing out of the place to promote it… naturally, they don’t approach girls. The funny thing about the area is the way people dress and look… you will find blonde Japanese guys… some even wearing make up… and in other parts girls who are wearing too much make up or kimonos in order to show to the pedestrians what to expect inside the shops.
We ended up in Izakaya, which is the Japanese local drink spots… they are not bars in the traditional sense.. they have tables and no counter drinking… you can order snacks or drinks depending on your liking… we had dinner there.. I got a pizza and my friends had eaten sort of soup with vegetables and chicken.. it came raw and was cooked on the table on a little moving gas cooker... of course, I didn’t even dare to taste it.. neither the look, texture or smell would have made it easier for me to try :)

Hakone, Gotenba outlet and Mount Fuji:

We decided to go to Hakone area where there is a premium outlet stores in Gotenba in order to shop in the sale and also see Mount Fuji… Mount Fuji is like Mont-Blanc is Switzerland… the top of it is always white because of snow… shopping would be fun in Japan if you are millionaire and you don’t travel a lot… the first is because you won’t care how much you are spending over a bag, shoes or any accessory.. the latter is because you will lack the edge of comparison… brands are way cheaper around the globe than in Japan.. yet again, the prices that are so expensive to the visitor are affordable to the Japanese… I am not talking about the rich Japanese who are driving Ferraris and Bentleys… I am talking about those driving Nissans or Mitsubishis… anyways.. we all ended up buying little things, which are normally extremely expensive, but we were able to spot few good bargains…
The view was beautiful and guess what? … Fauchon was a regular coffee place in the outlet… those from many parts of the world; especially Cairo would understand why I am commenting on that pastry shop rather than others :)

On our way back, I took over driving for the first time on the right side of the car… strange and confusing but on highways it is relatively ok…because there are no twists, bends or going left or right… it is just a straight line driving… thanks for the traffic jam.. it took us more than double the time… and I have beaten my record by driving most of the way abiding by the speed limit… the reasons are obvious.. . the first one was in relation to driving for the first time in a strange set up and a new country.. moreover, Mai was already in panic of the highway, mountains and I couldn’t afford scaring her more… so, in brief.. in the Guinness record of Namira, this night can be recorded for driving an entire highway without exceeding 100 km per hour :)

Wednesday, December 28, 2011

2011 quick sum up article original version to what got published in hebdo 28 December 2011

2011 turned to be a thriller to Egypt. Unexpectedly, the whole region went from political stagnation into a hotshot boiling point calling for change and aspirations to a better future. Egypt, after 30 years managed to oust Mubarak in February and put him to stand trial in August. The aftermath was leaving SCAF in power, lack of security, the rise of new political factions, including political Islam which left many of the Egyptians worried especially women and Copts. This article will address partially the events that Egypt of 2011 has witnessed.

The Fall of the last Pharaoh

On the 25th of January 2011 the day of the Police, Cairo woke up on mass protests, unprecedented since the bread riots of 1977.  The demonstrators called for putting an end to the emergency law, the brutality of the police and requesting to apply democracy and social justice. Few days later, numbers increased in all main squares of the Egyptian Governorates and they were met with extreme police brutality that led to hundreds of death and injuries. They maximized their calls after the reactions by Mubarak and his regime, to get rid of the last Pharaoh and his regime, until they managed on the 11th of February to do the first but failed to do the latter.

Although those who started the revolution belong mostly to the middle class, they were joined quickly with masses that were fed up of living under a regime that didn’t fulfill their aspirations nor had them on its radar. If freedom is one of the major reasons that started it all, it incorporated within freedom of fear, of speech, fighting corruption and aspiring for democracy, especially after the farce parliamentary elections that were held in November 2010 when the NDP swept all opposition and gained 100% of the seats of the People’s assembly. It has also included the call for social justice after the horrendous rise in food prices, living expenses and lack of employment opportunities to the youth.

The youth who were adamant to get the job done were mostly non-politicized; they didn’t belong to specific political party or group but they called for what they believed in and what touches their lives. Most of the political parties and the Muslim Brotherhood refused to join in with the demonstrators. Yet, some of the youth whether members of parties or the Brotherhood joined in their individual capacity the demonstrations failing to obey their leaders. These people wanted a better Egypt to live in and enjoy living in.

With the lack of pressure from abroad, the Pharaoh and his officials tried to maneuver but failed after the persistence of the street. The change of tide against them from the United States, her allies and the shift of the position of SCAF, which decided to save itself, paved the way to ousting the President. Even though Mubarak was and still is one of the Military establishment in Egypt, the leaders of the establishment well calculated their move by which they got rid of the groomed son Gamal and prevented him from succeeding his father in leading the State.

The outcome was a success in ousting Mubarak on the 11th of February, yet not the regime. In fact, in the last 11 months, Egypt has witnessed the recycling of the old guard of Mubarak in assuming different roles in running the country. Ministers, Prime Ministers, Governors, Directors of institutions, head of Public establishment are the same or those who were x-NDP and served directly with the ousted president. The revolution called for transparency and accountability in order to move forward. Nonetheless, Egyptians are still bewildered about incidents that took place starting with the Camel’s attack on demonstrators in Tahrir, passing through Mohamed Mahmoud and recently Kasr Eleini’s violence. Mubarak and his party are in Tora, yet, we didn’t witness any outcome to the trials. On the contrary, recently Suzan Mubarak and Zakaria Azmy- the chef de cabinet of the ousted President- were released temporarily until the trials take place. All this leads to further lack of faith in the institutions that are running the show. It adds to the frustration of people and leads to further instability. The comments by SCAF and the governments they appoint on each incident are directing their accusations to foreign hands or their parties. This is and won’t be satisfactory to the people, so the demonstrators keep going on and expected to continue regardless of the outcome of the parliamentary elections that are currently held in the country. This will advance the state into anarchy and divide it further. In fact if this is all planned through the divide and rule strategy, for SCAF it might be partially working on the short run but it won’t work on the long run when people realize that they were deceived.  

The rise of new political forces including Political Islam:

After the fall of Mubarak, many of the deprived political factions, especially those belonging to the Islamic political forces spoke out and started to prepare themselves to form political parties and join in into the political game. Moreover, other secular and youth parties also came into place and did their best to look appealing to the Egyptian voters.

However, the short period that was given to the newly born political factions deprived them from privileges Islamist factions enjoy; sympathy for suffering by the security apparatus of the ousted president, organization, funding and the divine word. Although, the laws regulating the political game in Egypt criminalizes using religion in politics, yet the lack of the rule of law was flagrant in this case and during both the referendum of March on the 1971 constitutional amendments and the ongoing elections that started in November. This raises doubts that SCAF and the US support the role of the Brotherhood. SCAF was lenient in applying the laws of elections, political parties and foreign funding on the Brotherhood and the US reconfirmed its will to cooperate with them preserve its interests and that of Israel’s. Hence, while Islamist factions using legal or illegal tools managed to get majority in parliament, the Brotherhood replaced the NDP in running the show.

Regardless of how they succeeded in hijacking the revolution, the Brotherhood represents hope and fear to the society. While the focus of many hardliners in the Brotherhood, jama’h Islamiya and the Nour party causes threats to; individual freedoms and liberties that the revolution called for, social justice, as their leaders are mostly rich business people of technocrats, certain sectors like tourism industry, minorities and deprived factions of the society including Copts, women, Shiites and other religious minorities in Egypt, they represent hope to other deprived faction of the community that voted for the divine word in the hope of fighting corruption and aspiring for bettering their lives.

Their job ahead is huge and if they won’t balance striving for power with real reform rather than further oppression, Egypt will face more instability than what she has already witnessed during 2011.

Egyptian minorities including Copts and the rising of political Islam

2011 started by an attack on the Saints Church in Alexandria on the first day of the New Year, during which 23 Copts and Muslims died and around 97 were injured. The former Minister of Interior Habib Eladly accused the Gaza based Army of Islam as the perpetrator of the attack, while they denied it. Later, it was said that the -supposedly- dismantled state security was the mastermind of the deadly attack on that church. The truth is yet to be revealed, if the investigations are carried out and those responsible for that attack stand trials.

 While the 25th of January revolution proved that Egyptians from all paths of life and different religions stood hand in hand against the tyranny and brutality of the security apparatus of Mubarak, however, the lack of security and rule of law led to other tragic incidents of sectarian violence and clashes between the Muslim majority and the Christian minority.

Some incidents were contained on ad hoc basis; like signing an agreement between the victim and torturer granting pardon to those who burnt the house and cut the ear of the Coptic teacher Ayman Metri from Qena, rebuilding the church in Atfih in Sol village by the Army or containing the violence in Imbaba after the attack on a church for keeping a Coptic girl inside who converted to Islam. Yet, the lack of accountability in any of these incidents led to further attacks or incitements, until a controversial problem started in Aswan regarding a private place used for worship and doubted to be converted into a church. The problem was solved in Aswan, but violence erupted in Cairo in what is now known as the Maspero Massacre, in order to support the call for a fair law for building Churches.

Now, the whole game has a different dimension for the minorities in Egypt; women are so far threatened that they will be obligated to wear the veil, occupy certain professions or stay home and forget about the dream of equality, nevertheless, those who had already suffered and threatened to suffer further by the rise of political Islam are the Copts. In the political maneuvers minorities received some words of composure while others threaten them. This game is still ongoing but the deprivation of freedom of choice, religion or path might be getting nearer than we expected.

 

 

 

Thursday, December 8, 2011

Egyptian expats to vote

A la veille des elections legislatives prevues le mois prochain, l'une des questions sur le tapis est cells du droit de vote pour les egyptiens expatries.

8 October 2011 was named the day for a virtual invitation that was dispatched on Facebook to encourage Egyptians living abroad to demonstrate in front of the Egyptian Embassies and Consulates and in front of the Cabinet of Ministers in Cairo to support the droit de vote pour les egyptiens expatries. They called for sending committees to speedily issue national identity cards to the expats, amend the law for political rights, establishing mechanisms to allow Egyptian expats to vote. An official of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said, “there was only one demonstration that took place in front of the Egyptian Embassy in Washington D.C.”
Egyptian expats are interested in voting in the upcoming elections and they don’t feel alienated from their home country or its problems, Ayman Tarshouby from Australia, said, “it is a matter of dignity and pride. When finally Egyptians get the right to be heard, it is important that all should be heard without depriving part of the community from that right.” Others from Canada, United States and Japan agreed on their eagerness to vote in the upcoming elections. Some are already checking with embassies and consulates as to when they will vote. They confirmed that Living abroad doesn’t make them alienated from their homeland and regardless of their status; students, professionals or investors, they believed that they have an inalienable right to vote and have a say in their country’s future. On the other hand, they confirmed that the Egyptian expats will be so disappointed in the absence of allowing them to vote and they made it clear that the onus of the blame will be borne by Ministry of Foreign Affairs represented in the embassies and consulates abroad, because few will understand the exact mechanism within the government to allow Egyptians living abroad to vote.
The number of Egyptians living abroad is approximately between 7 to 8 million people. Around 74% of them live in Arab countries while 26% live in Western countries, including Australia and New Zealand. Moreover, the remittances of Egyptians abroad are an important asset to the economy of Egypt. According to a report by the Central Bank of Egypt, remittances of Egyptians abroad increased from 9.8 billion USD in the fiscal year 2009/2010 to 12.6 billion USD in 2010/2011. Despite their contribution to the economy of their origin, the issue of allowing Egyptians abroad to vote has been subject to debate for a long time and no conclusion was reached so far. One expat from Japan said that while Egypt is seeking their support to reconstruct Egypt and invest in the country after the revolution, it will be so difficult to show real interest and solidarity while deprived from their right to vote in elections.
SCAF issued message number 49 in April 2011 to confirm that no decision is taken to ban Egyptian expats from voting as claimed through the media. Later, in September General Mamdouh Shaheen, Assistant Minister of Defence and Member of CSFA confirmed the legitimacy of the call of the expats to vote, but he spoke of the difficulty that SCAF can’t assign a judge to monitor elections in every place where the Egyptian Expats reside and it is not possible to hold elections without judicial supervision. He said that it is necessary to look into different options to solve this issue. Summing up, he stated that all the issues relating to voting rights of Egyptian abroad and other matters regarding elections are all within the competence of the Supreme Committee for Elections and not within the competence of SCAF.
Moreover, Officials from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs stated that to grant the Egyptian expats that right, it requires a decision from the Supreme Committee for Elections. At the same time, Justice Abd El Moez Ibrahim, Chief of the Cairo Court of Appeal and Chair of the Supreme Committee for Elections stated that Egyptian expats voting requires a sovereign decision and it is not within the competence of the Committee to issue it.
Commenting on these contradictory statements, Dr. Gamal Soltan, analyst and Lecturer of Politics at the American University in Cairo said that “he believes that the supreme leadership in the army is troubled to take a decision that will change the familiar electoral base that it knows because the predictability will be jeopardized. Hence, this will limit the effects of the supreme leadership on the process.” He added, “There are so many political views and contradictory analysis about the issue, nevertheless, the comments is an attempt by SCAF to run away from the responsibility and hurl it to others. The others know that the decision is out of their domain and the statement by the Supreme Committee for Elections leads to the embarrassment of SCAF.”
Mr. Soltan also spoke of the difficulties that the Government may encounter in order to guarantee the assistance of the host states where there are big numbers of Egyptian expatriates, he said “in the lack of studies about the issue, hypothetically, some states may not welcome the move, especially in the Gulf where there is a big Egyptian community and the supreme ideology is conservative.” He added that “Egypt is passing though difficult unusual times and the upcoming elections are very important not only for Egyptians, but also internationally and regionally. Hence, a pertinent question arises on how far the host states will not interfere in the electoral process which may further the uncertainty of the outcome. Moreover, legitimacy issues may arise due to the difference between host States, not with regard to casting the vote as such but in the political differences and how far this will affect the legality of the process.” Confirming this view, A Diplomat from a Gulf States stated that “cooperation may not be granted by some Gulf States to the Egyptian embassies and consulates, for 2 main reasons, the fear of huge blocks of Egyptians gathering in one place which may cause not only logistical but security problems and may lead to clashes between them and the authority representatives who will assist in organizing the process. The other aspect is the fear in some conservative societies of spreading the culture of elections among their nationals, bearing in mind the big numbers of Egyptians in comparison to the westerners who vote in their embassies in the Gulf Countries.”
One hypothetical issue the Dr. Soltan has raised and no one spoke of so far the issue of “no tax, no representation,” which states that if one is not a tax payer or evade paying taxes then one shouldn’t have a say in the representation in the country. Expats commenting on this point stated, “Most of those who don’t pay taxes in Egypt evade it because they don’t find a true justification for it, although they pay high taxes to the foreign governments of the states they live in. They do the latter because; they get services in return to their taxes from good health care, to education to others, which is different than the situation in Egypt. Furthermore, if in Egypt, voters are not deprived from that right whether they pay their taxes or not, then the expats should be granted the same right.”
One official from the Egyptian Ministry of Foreign Affairs confirmed that “the right of expats to vote is indisputable and it should be organized to take place, but MFA is an implementer and not a decision maker in the matter.” she added, “it is feasible to open the door for expats to vote in elections but there will be a need to gather full information about the exact numbers of Egyptians who have the right to vote in every country, Consular missions and embassies will need to visit Egyptian blocks in collaboration with the local authorities, in order to reach out to people and build confidence among them in the process. This will require support for; the human resources available at the missions, financial and security support. Logistical support will also be required; to issue the national identity card to the expats, unless they will be allowed to use their passports and the machines to count the votes.” She also confirmed that from her experience, “many countries especially western countries will lend the necessary support to our missions abroad during the elections.”

exchange of prisoners between Hamas in Gaza

On 11 October 2011 a final deal of exchange of prisoners between Hamas in Gaza and the Israeli Government took place with Egyptian Mediation efforts. The deal marked a success on behalf of the interim government of Egypt. An Israeli soldier, Gilat Shalit, then 19, was abducted on 25 June 2006 by a joint force of Palestinian militants who tunnelled under the Gaza-Israel border, ambushing an Israeli army post. He stayed in captivation for almost 5 years by Hamas. In exchange for Shalit, Israel agreed to release 1027 Palestinian prisoners, among them leaders in Hamas. The first stage of the swap took place on 18 October 2011 when Israel released 477 Palestinian prisoners when Shalit physically reached Israel. While agreeing to release these prisoners, Israel pledged to lift the long lived siege on the Gaza Strip.
If the deal is considered a success to both Hamas and Israel, it might be seen at representing a shift in the Egyptian leadership in the Palestinian Cause. Ismail Hanya, the Chief of the dismissed Palestinian Government in Gaza, thanked the revolutionary Egypt for its role in leading the negotiations and assuming the responsibility of the Great Egypt in sponsoring the Palestinian will.
While attempting to figure out the implications of the Shalit deal on the internal affairs of Egypt and the posture of its interim government on all levels; nationally, regionally and internationally, Mr Ahmed Tohamy, a researcher in the school of Government and International affairs at Durham University, he confirmed, “the timing of the execution of the deal was chosen prudently by all parties, not only Hamas and Israel but also the Egyptian mediator. The timing was good; for Netanyahu who is seeking internal legitimacy to face the criticism of the left against his neoliberal policies and the threats to the Israeli national security especially after the tensions with turkey, for Hamas who is seeking legitimacy over Fatah after the attempt to have a full membership at the UN. As for the Egyptian party, we discover that the timing coincided with the events in Maspero. Yet, he said it is somehow difficult to consider that this coincidence was meant to happen, but it was used to the best. The new Egyptian system that was formed after the revolution aspires for building new popular legitimacy in order to better the image of SCAF internally and externally. The pending issues like Shalit Case presented an opportunity to turn it into gains and new legitimacy in the internal affairs.” He stated, “negotiations process of that issue requires a long time and from a theoretical and historical perspectives the Arab Israeli conflict was always an important tool in affecting the internal affairs; whether to gain popular legitimacy through assembling the people behind the political leadership as long as it faces an external threat or through insinuating that amazing achievements on the external affairs that relatively cover up the failure in the internal policies.”
Moreover, when considering the effect of the deal on the Egyptian role in the Palestinian quest, Mr. Tohamy said, “after the 25th of January revolution, the Egyptian politics is attempting to play an active role in the Arab-Israeli conflict, which bestows upon it internal legitimacy and covers up the internal failures and regardless of the fact that the Palestinian Cause is an issue of national security for Egypt, but it is also used to bring popular support.” He added, “This was evident in the Egyptian efforts to bring into fruition the national reconciliation between Fatah and Hamas on one hand, and the prisoners deal on the other. In fact, Cairo wants to get rid of the bad reputation it has acquired during Mubarak’s ruling that it has been in complicity with Israel and wants to build a new role as a partner to the Palestinian party that can play the effective role of moderating between it and Israel.”
He stressed, “The United States and Israel need an active Egyptian role in that cause and there is an international strategic decision to support the Egyptian regime and SCAF. This was evident in the persistence to prevent the escalation of tension after storming the Israeli embassy in Cairo and the Israeli apology for the killing of the Egyptian soldiers on the borders and a blind eye was turned on many of the internal policies.” He added, “this role became more crucial especially after the Syrian revolt and the decline in the Syrian role in supporting the Palestinian opposition, which is also an important factor in bringing Hamas to the negotiating terms and is changing their hostility with Mubarak’s regime to a more partnership terms with the new regime in Egypt to the point of negotiating opening an office to represent Hamas in Cairo. This is serving the latter in seeking the approval of the Islamist factions in Egypt.” From her point of view, Sherine Elghatit, Professor of Political Science at AUC, “the attack on the Israeli Embassy in Cairo was directed against the Egyptian Government more than Israel. People were mad at the interim government for not taking a strong stand towards the death of the Egyptian soldiers. As for the exchange of Prisoners, the timing was a surprise. But it says a lot about the Israeli policies in the wake of the Arab Spring and the realization that things won’t be always on their own terms, they had to find a another way to proceed that is why we have witnessed such rapid developments on that front.”
As for the Security in Sinai, Mr. Tohamy stated, “in the recent years, Sinai is suffering from strategic and security vacuum, which comprises a predicament to all parties. This situation tempts many of the Salafist, Jihadist, regional and international security services to play an active role in Sinai. The recent incidents with the continuous attacks on the gas pipelines, the violence in Arish and Eilat operations all indicate the presence of new players in the Peninsula. This dilemma stems from the Peace Treaty of 1979 that restricts the Egyptian freedom in deploying more troops in Sinai. Yet, the negative impacts of these incidents on Israeli interests and security make the Israeli government, though hesitant, more open to negotiations aiming at increasing the Egyptian Army troops there. Moreover, a friendly Hamas will collaborate with Egypt in order to control the passage of Jihadist members from Gaza into Sinai. Hence, we can consider the last breakthroughs a shift in the Egyptian policy toward Hamas, but it is early to judge its parameters. And to sum up, the last events took place because of the interests involved to the other parties, not only the Egyptian efforts and definitely, if the internal situation in Egypt is more solid, we would achieve much more in our external affairs.”

“Secretive” Constitutional Declaration "

Egypt has witnessed a new Constitutional Declaration when SCAF issued a “Secretive” Constitutional Declaration on the 25th of February 2011. They said it is complementary to the previous Declarations issued to regulate steering the administration of the Republic until the people of Egypt elect a new Parliament and a new president.
This declaration consisted of one provision dealing with the electoral process and it addressed the allocation of seats in both houses of the parliament ( the people’s assembly and the Shoura Council). Under this provision, two thirds of seats of the People's Assembly and the Shura Council would be filled under the proportional list system and one third of seats will filled through the individual system.
SCAF issued the declaration and published it in the official gazette in isolation from all political forces in the country, which eventually lead to widespread condemnation from some of them as stated in Elmasry Elyoum newspaper on 28 September 2011 that “They (referring to SCAF) added that the decision to restrict publication of the declaration to the Official Gazette reflects a state of confusion within the military council. “They cannot just publish it without putting it up for a political dialogue,” said Mohamed al-Qassas of the Islamist Egyptian Trend Party.
While on the other hand, General Mamdouh Shaheen Assistant Minister of Defence for Legal Affairs and Member of SCAF stated to the Ahram Gate on the 30th of September that there was a need for this declaration because the previous declarations do not allow a change in the proportions allocated between those elected on the list and those elected as individuals. Moreover, he added that SCAF has an absolute power to issue constitutional declarations during the transitional period.
Now, Egypt had so far three constitutional declarations issued since the revolt of January 2011. The first Declaration was issued directly on 13th of February 2011 after the announcement that Mubarak had given up power and delegated SCAF to take over running the country until a new government is formed, the second Declaration was issued on the 31st of March 2011 after a public referendum that approved amendments to the 1971 Constitution which was already put on hold at the time. Hence, this dilemma presents several questions, whether the second constitution was legal or not? Is it true that SCAF has absolute power to issue declarations during the transitional period? What are the consequences of all these changes on the political, legal and economic situation of the country?
While seeking answers to these questions, Professor Sherine Elghatit from the Political Science Department at AUC stated that the main characteristic of a government in transition that it should only confine itself to the role of a care taker government. Therefore, it works in accordance with the existing laws and regulations because there are no legitimate legislative institutions in place. However, in the case of Egypt, the Consecutive Constitutional Declarations failed to set a time frame to the transitional period. Furthermore, it has granted SCAF the absolute power to issue decrees of laws without any restrictions to the types of legislation they can issue or with regard to their substance. In fact, this is in contradiction with the revolutionary legitimacy that requires confining the promulgation of laws to those that represent the will of the revolutionary people. This further entails that these laws are those concerned with the upcoming elections only, like the electoral and parties laws.”
She added, “Concerning the consecutive Constitutional Declarations, the Egyptian people were dragged to the referendum without real use or benefit to the democratic process. Furthermore, the legitimacy of the Second Constitutional Declaration is subject to doubts because it has altered the will of the people. ”
As for the consequences of these measures on the situation of Egypt, she stated “Granting SCAF absolute power to issue legislation without any restrictions leads to a worrisome legal and political situation. It opens the door to amend any of the existing legislation in education, health, personal Status, commerce, tourism and others, which freezes the flow of investments into Egypt, because the foreign and local investors are uncertain to what may take place between one day and another. Hence, unfortunately the poor and not the rich people will be the most affected by that situation. They will lose their jobs and they won’t find a substitute because no new jobs are created in the absence of the flow of investments. Furthermore, if the legal uncertainty phase is prolonged we will witness further deterioration and more investments that will close down and pull out of the Egyptian market.”

The Salemy’s Document 2011

While the elections are approaching, a heated ongoing debate is taking place on another attempt to issue a new document for Supra Constitutional Principles came to light last week by the Deputy Prime Minister, Dr. Ali Elselmy.
The Salemy’s Document addressed rights and freedoms and also granted the Military a prominent position in the new constitution; Articles 9 and 10 put the Military as the sole guarantor of the constitutional legitimacy in the country, its budget shall be confidential and not to be discussed in the Parliament. Moreover, the Document attempted to lay criteria for choosing the 100 members of the Constitutional Assembly, 80% of them will be chosen and only 20% left to the Parliament to. After concerns rose by political factions, on 14 November, Dr. Elselmy deleted from Article 9 and 10 that the Army is the sole guarantor of the constitution and its budget will be reviewed by the National Security Council chaired by the president.
On Sunday 13 November, the Democratic Coalition for Egypt met in the premises of the freedom and justice party to discuss the document and issued a statement agreeing to abide by the Al Azhar document, confirming that the Constitutional Assembly should encompass all factions in the community and that issues of the Military that concerns the national security should be taken into consideration while drafting the new constitution. Commenting on this Statement, Mr. Abu ElEla Mady, the Chief of ElWasat Party, that shared in drafting the Statement, stated that the Coalition agreed with most of the articles of the Document, except for articles 9 and 10. He ensured, “the Armed Forces, as part of the executive branch of the State has to abide by the Constitution and the law and its budget has to be discussed by the Parliament in confidential meetings as is the case democratic systems.”
Mr. Shahir George, Member of Egypt Freedom Party who is running in the upcoming elections as part of the Coalition of the Revolution Continues, stated, “we are against granting the Military immunity or granting it rights in choosing the members of the Constitutional Assembly. The amendment to review the military budget by the National Security Council is a good step, yet the target should be its revision by the Parliament. The timing of the Document is bad due to the proximity to the elections.” He confirmed, “we support a consensus guidelines Document with the approval of the Egyptian people in a referendum. Parliament members should choose the members of the Assembly whether from among them or outside. but we are against any imposition of certain members by SCAF.” Dr. Dina Shehata, Senior Researcher at Al-Ahram Centre for Political and Strategic Studies stressed that the problem lied in the process. Dr. Elselmy prepared Constitutional Principles in the absence of any dialogue with political factions in a manner of “take it or leave it”. Furthermore, Dr. Shehata said, “it is not foreseen that the new constitution will come out without granting the military immunities, but it comes up as a compromise not enforced by the Government.” Also, Dr. Samer Soliman, Founding Member of the Egyptian Democratic Social Party, agreed that there process is the problem. He said, “the party refuses any a political role for the Military. We are against any military or religious state and contrary to the Islamite factions, we believe that drafting the constitution should not be left to the faction with the majority in the parliament.” He added, “we can agree to a consensus document that guarantees the political rights and democracy, with guarantees that all will abide by it.” He confirmed, “the amendments are steps in the right direction towards our goals. Islamite factions predict that they will gain the majority in the parliament and they want to dominate writing the new constitution. They endorsed the Azhar document because of its general nature.”
Commenting on the whole difference, Professor Ezzedine Fishere of AUC said “liberals want a document to serve as a guarantee to respect democracy and freedoms. This is the most important factor for them because it helps alleviate their worries from the Islamite factions. On the contrary, Islamite factions don’t want to give any concessions hoping that they will win the majority so they’ve more space to maneuver. In fact, Islamite factions agreed to join forces with other political factions in opposing the expansion of the role of the military isolate SCAF and the Government predicting that this fight may kill the document. However, if the liberals agreed to the document then the Islamite factions will be left alone. By all means, this document is not the right place to discuss the role of the Military, SCAF is still in power and we have ample time to discuss this issue at length.”

IMBABA

بعد أقل من 24 ساعة من نشر المقال حول خطوات الإصلاح الأمنى نشبت معارك فى منطقة إمبابة بين المسلمين والأقباط فى المنطقة مما أسفر عن قتلى وجرحى وتحول المكان إلى منطقة حرب حتى فجر اليوم التالى بعد تدخل القوات الأمنية بعنف لفض الإشتباك، مما أدى إلى أن انتابنى الشعور بأننى "أنفخ فى قربة مقطوعة"، وبدأ نوع من اليأس والإحباط يندس فى مخيلتى واسترجعت مقولة زعيم الأمة سعد زغلول عن مرضه إن "مفيش فايدة"، إلا أن رؤية ما يحدث على كورنيش النيل أمام مبنى الإذاعة والتلفزيون بماسبيرو وانتشار الأمن المركزى لتأمين المتظاهرين جعلنى استحضر ما قاله نابليون بأن "مفيش مستحيل".

وبالفعل أنا على قناعة تامة بأن مفيش مستحيل وأن الوضع الأمنى سوف يتحسن بعد تدهور، حتى مع توقع المزيد، إلا أن تحسين الوضع الأمنى يقتضى وبلا جدال إلى جانب إصلاح القطاع الأمنى تكريس مفهوم سيادة القانون من قبل الجميع، المواطنين والقائمين على تنفيذ القانون. فى الوضع المصرى الراهن، نحن فى أمس حاجة لتنفيذ قانون العقوبات والقوانين الأخرى المرتبطة بها وغيرها من القوانين الخاصة بالحفاظ على الأمن العام فى البلاد.