A la veille des elections legislatives prevues le mois prochain, l'une des questions sur le tapis est cells du droit de vote pour les egyptiens expatries.
8 October 2011 was named the day for a virtual invitation that was dispatched on Facebook to encourage Egyptians living abroad to demonstrate in front of the Egyptian Embassies and Consulates and in front of the Cabinet of Ministers in Cairo to support the droit de vote pour les egyptiens expatries. They called for sending committees to speedily issue national identity cards to the expats, amend the law for political rights, establishing mechanisms to allow Egyptian expats to vote. An official of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said, “there was only one demonstration that took place in front of the Egyptian Embassy in Washington D.C.”
Egyptian expats are interested in voting in the upcoming elections and they don’t feel alienated from their home country or its problems, Ayman Tarshouby from Australia, said, “it is a matter of dignity and pride. When finally Egyptians get the right to be heard, it is important that all should be heard without depriving part of the community from that right.” Others from Canada, United States and Japan agreed on their eagerness to vote in the upcoming elections. Some are already checking with embassies and consulates as to when they will vote. They confirmed that Living abroad doesn’t make them alienated from their homeland and regardless of their status; students, professionals or investors, they believed that they have an inalienable right to vote and have a say in their country’s future. On the other hand, they confirmed that the Egyptian expats will be so disappointed in the absence of allowing them to vote and they made it clear that the onus of the blame will be borne by Ministry of Foreign Affairs represented in the embassies and consulates abroad, because few will understand the exact mechanism within the government to allow Egyptians living abroad to vote.
The number of Egyptians living abroad is approximately between 7 to 8 million people. Around 74% of them live in Arab countries while 26% live in Western countries, including Australia and New Zealand. Moreover, the remittances of Egyptians abroad are an important asset to the economy of Egypt. According to a report by the Central Bank of Egypt, remittances of Egyptians abroad increased from 9.8 billion USD in the fiscal year 2009/2010 to 12.6 billion USD in 2010/2011. Despite their contribution to the economy of their origin, the issue of allowing Egyptians abroad to vote has been subject to debate for a long time and no conclusion was reached so far. One expat from Japan said that while Egypt is seeking their support to reconstruct Egypt and invest in the country after the revolution, it will be so difficult to show real interest and solidarity while deprived from their right to vote in elections.
SCAF issued message number 49 in April 2011 to confirm that no decision is taken to ban Egyptian expats from voting as claimed through the media. Later, in September General Mamdouh Shaheen, Assistant Minister of Defence and Member of CSFA confirmed the legitimacy of the call of the expats to vote, but he spoke of the difficulty that SCAF can’t assign a judge to monitor elections in every place where the Egyptian Expats reside and it is not possible to hold elections without judicial supervision. He said that it is necessary to look into different options to solve this issue. Summing up, he stated that all the issues relating to voting rights of Egyptian abroad and other matters regarding elections are all within the competence of the Supreme Committee for Elections and not within the competence of SCAF.
Moreover, Officials from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs stated that to grant the Egyptian expats that right, it requires a decision from the Supreme Committee for Elections. At the same time, Justice Abd El Moez Ibrahim, Chief of the Cairo Court of Appeal and Chair of the Supreme Committee for Elections stated that Egyptian expats voting requires a sovereign decision and it is not within the competence of the Committee to issue it.
Commenting on these contradictory statements, Dr. Gamal Soltan, analyst and Lecturer of Politics at the American University in Cairo said that “he believes that the supreme leadership in the army is troubled to take a decision that will change the familiar electoral base that it knows because the predictability will be jeopardized. Hence, this will limit the effects of the supreme leadership on the process.” He added, “There are so many political views and contradictory analysis about the issue, nevertheless, the comments is an attempt by SCAF to run away from the responsibility and hurl it to others. The others know that the decision is out of their domain and the statement by the Supreme Committee for Elections leads to the embarrassment of SCAF.”
Mr. Soltan also spoke of the difficulties that the Government may encounter in order to guarantee the assistance of the host states where there are big numbers of Egyptian expatriates, he said “in the lack of studies about the issue, hypothetically, some states may not welcome the move, especially in the Gulf where there is a big Egyptian community and the supreme ideology is conservative.” He added that “Egypt is passing though difficult unusual times and the upcoming elections are very important not only for Egyptians, but also internationally and regionally. Hence, a pertinent question arises on how far the host states will not interfere in the electoral process which may further the uncertainty of the outcome. Moreover, legitimacy issues may arise due to the difference between host States, not with regard to casting the vote as such but in the political differences and how far this will affect the legality of the process.” Confirming this view, A Diplomat from a Gulf States stated that “cooperation may not be granted by some Gulf States to the Egyptian embassies and consulates, for 2 main reasons, the fear of huge blocks of Egyptians gathering in one place which may cause not only logistical but security problems and may lead to clashes between them and the authority representatives who will assist in organizing the process. The other aspect is the fear in some conservative societies of spreading the culture of elections among their nationals, bearing in mind the big numbers of Egyptians in comparison to the westerners who vote in their embassies in the Gulf Countries.”
One hypothetical issue the Dr. Soltan has raised and no one spoke of so far the issue of “no tax, no representation,” which states that if one is not a tax payer or evade paying taxes then one shouldn’t have a say in the representation in the country. Expats commenting on this point stated, “Most of those who don’t pay taxes in Egypt evade it because they don’t find a true justification for it, although they pay high taxes to the foreign governments of the states they live in. They do the latter because; they get services in return to their taxes from good health care, to education to others, which is different than the situation in Egypt. Furthermore, if in Egypt, voters are not deprived from that right whether they pay their taxes or not, then the expats should be granted the same right.”
One official from the Egyptian Ministry of Foreign Affairs confirmed that “the right of expats to vote is indisputable and it should be organized to take place, but MFA is an implementer and not a decision maker in the matter.” she added, “it is feasible to open the door for expats to vote in elections but there will be a need to gather full information about the exact numbers of Egyptians who have the right to vote in every country, Consular missions and embassies will need to visit Egyptian blocks in collaboration with the local authorities, in order to reach out to people and build confidence among them in the process. This will require support for; the human resources available at the missions, financial and security support. Logistical support will also be required; to issue the national identity card to the expats, unless they will be allowed to use their passports and the machines to count the votes.” She also confirmed that from her experience, “many countries especially western countries will lend the necessary support to our missions abroad during the elections.”
Thursday, December 8, 2011
exchange of prisoners between Hamas in Gaza
On 11 October 2011 a final deal of exchange of prisoners between Hamas in Gaza and the Israeli Government took place with Egyptian Mediation efforts. The deal marked a success on behalf of the interim government of Egypt. An Israeli soldier, Gilat Shalit, then 19, was abducted on 25 June 2006 by a joint force of Palestinian militants who tunnelled under the Gaza-Israel border, ambushing an Israeli army post. He stayed in captivation for almost 5 years by Hamas. In exchange for Shalit, Israel agreed to release 1027 Palestinian prisoners, among them leaders in Hamas. The first stage of the swap took place on 18 October 2011 when Israel released 477 Palestinian prisoners when Shalit physically reached Israel. While agreeing to release these prisoners, Israel pledged to lift the long lived siege on the Gaza Strip.
If the deal is considered a success to both Hamas and Israel, it might be seen at representing a shift in the Egyptian leadership in the Palestinian Cause. Ismail Hanya, the Chief of the dismissed Palestinian Government in Gaza, thanked the revolutionary Egypt for its role in leading the negotiations and assuming the responsibility of the Great Egypt in sponsoring the Palestinian will.
While attempting to figure out the implications of the Shalit deal on the internal affairs of Egypt and the posture of its interim government on all levels; nationally, regionally and internationally, Mr Ahmed Tohamy, a researcher in the school of Government and International affairs at Durham University, he confirmed, “the timing of the execution of the deal was chosen prudently by all parties, not only Hamas and Israel but also the Egyptian mediator. The timing was good; for Netanyahu who is seeking internal legitimacy to face the criticism of the left against his neoliberal policies and the threats to the Israeli national security especially after the tensions with turkey, for Hamas who is seeking legitimacy over Fatah after the attempt to have a full membership at the UN. As for the Egyptian party, we discover that the timing coincided with the events in Maspero. Yet, he said it is somehow difficult to consider that this coincidence was meant to happen, but it was used to the best. The new Egyptian system that was formed after the revolution aspires for building new popular legitimacy in order to better the image of SCAF internally and externally. The pending issues like Shalit Case presented an opportunity to turn it into gains and new legitimacy in the internal affairs.” He stated, “negotiations process of that issue requires a long time and from a theoretical and historical perspectives the Arab Israeli conflict was always an important tool in affecting the internal affairs; whether to gain popular legitimacy through assembling the people behind the political leadership as long as it faces an external threat or through insinuating that amazing achievements on the external affairs that relatively cover up the failure in the internal policies.”
Moreover, when considering the effect of the deal on the Egyptian role in the Palestinian quest, Mr. Tohamy said, “after the 25th of January revolution, the Egyptian politics is attempting to play an active role in the Arab-Israeli conflict, which bestows upon it internal legitimacy and covers up the internal failures and regardless of the fact that the Palestinian Cause is an issue of national security for Egypt, but it is also used to bring popular support.” He added, “This was evident in the Egyptian efforts to bring into fruition the national reconciliation between Fatah and Hamas on one hand, and the prisoners deal on the other. In fact, Cairo wants to get rid of the bad reputation it has acquired during Mubarak’s ruling that it has been in complicity with Israel and wants to build a new role as a partner to the Palestinian party that can play the effective role of moderating between it and Israel.”
He stressed, “The United States and Israel need an active Egyptian role in that cause and there is an international strategic decision to support the Egyptian regime and SCAF. This was evident in the persistence to prevent the escalation of tension after storming the Israeli embassy in Cairo and the Israeli apology for the killing of the Egyptian soldiers on the borders and a blind eye was turned on many of the internal policies.” He added, “this role became more crucial especially after the Syrian revolt and the decline in the Syrian role in supporting the Palestinian opposition, which is also an important factor in bringing Hamas to the negotiating terms and is changing their hostility with Mubarak’s regime to a more partnership terms with the new regime in Egypt to the point of negotiating opening an office to represent Hamas in Cairo. This is serving the latter in seeking the approval of the Islamist factions in Egypt.” From her point of view, Sherine Elghatit, Professor of Political Science at AUC, “the attack on the Israeli Embassy in Cairo was directed against the Egyptian Government more than Israel. People were mad at the interim government for not taking a strong stand towards the death of the Egyptian soldiers. As for the exchange of Prisoners, the timing was a surprise. But it says a lot about the Israeli policies in the wake of the Arab Spring and the realization that things won’t be always on their own terms, they had to find a another way to proceed that is why we have witnessed such rapid developments on that front.”
As for the Security in Sinai, Mr. Tohamy stated, “in the recent years, Sinai is suffering from strategic and security vacuum, which comprises a predicament to all parties. This situation tempts many of the Salafist, Jihadist, regional and international security services to play an active role in Sinai. The recent incidents with the continuous attacks on the gas pipelines, the violence in Arish and Eilat operations all indicate the presence of new players in the Peninsula. This dilemma stems from the Peace Treaty of 1979 that restricts the Egyptian freedom in deploying more troops in Sinai. Yet, the negative impacts of these incidents on Israeli interests and security make the Israeli government, though hesitant, more open to negotiations aiming at increasing the Egyptian Army troops there. Moreover, a friendly Hamas will collaborate with Egypt in order to control the passage of Jihadist members from Gaza into Sinai. Hence, we can consider the last breakthroughs a shift in the Egyptian policy toward Hamas, but it is early to judge its parameters. And to sum up, the last events took place because of the interests involved to the other parties, not only the Egyptian efforts and definitely, if the internal situation in Egypt is more solid, we would achieve much more in our external affairs.”
If the deal is considered a success to both Hamas and Israel, it might be seen at representing a shift in the Egyptian leadership in the Palestinian Cause. Ismail Hanya, the Chief of the dismissed Palestinian Government in Gaza, thanked the revolutionary Egypt for its role in leading the negotiations and assuming the responsibility of the Great Egypt in sponsoring the Palestinian will.
While attempting to figure out the implications of the Shalit deal on the internal affairs of Egypt and the posture of its interim government on all levels; nationally, regionally and internationally, Mr Ahmed Tohamy, a researcher in the school of Government and International affairs at Durham University, he confirmed, “the timing of the execution of the deal was chosen prudently by all parties, not only Hamas and Israel but also the Egyptian mediator. The timing was good; for Netanyahu who is seeking internal legitimacy to face the criticism of the left against his neoliberal policies and the threats to the Israeli national security especially after the tensions with turkey, for Hamas who is seeking legitimacy over Fatah after the attempt to have a full membership at the UN. As for the Egyptian party, we discover that the timing coincided with the events in Maspero. Yet, he said it is somehow difficult to consider that this coincidence was meant to happen, but it was used to the best. The new Egyptian system that was formed after the revolution aspires for building new popular legitimacy in order to better the image of SCAF internally and externally. The pending issues like Shalit Case presented an opportunity to turn it into gains and new legitimacy in the internal affairs.” He stated, “negotiations process of that issue requires a long time and from a theoretical and historical perspectives the Arab Israeli conflict was always an important tool in affecting the internal affairs; whether to gain popular legitimacy through assembling the people behind the political leadership as long as it faces an external threat or through insinuating that amazing achievements on the external affairs that relatively cover up the failure in the internal policies.”
Moreover, when considering the effect of the deal on the Egyptian role in the Palestinian quest, Mr. Tohamy said, “after the 25th of January revolution, the Egyptian politics is attempting to play an active role in the Arab-Israeli conflict, which bestows upon it internal legitimacy and covers up the internal failures and regardless of the fact that the Palestinian Cause is an issue of national security for Egypt, but it is also used to bring popular support.” He added, “This was evident in the Egyptian efforts to bring into fruition the national reconciliation between Fatah and Hamas on one hand, and the prisoners deal on the other. In fact, Cairo wants to get rid of the bad reputation it has acquired during Mubarak’s ruling that it has been in complicity with Israel and wants to build a new role as a partner to the Palestinian party that can play the effective role of moderating between it and Israel.”
He stressed, “The United States and Israel need an active Egyptian role in that cause and there is an international strategic decision to support the Egyptian regime and SCAF. This was evident in the persistence to prevent the escalation of tension after storming the Israeli embassy in Cairo and the Israeli apology for the killing of the Egyptian soldiers on the borders and a blind eye was turned on many of the internal policies.” He added, “this role became more crucial especially after the Syrian revolt and the decline in the Syrian role in supporting the Palestinian opposition, which is also an important factor in bringing Hamas to the negotiating terms and is changing their hostility with Mubarak’s regime to a more partnership terms with the new regime in Egypt to the point of negotiating opening an office to represent Hamas in Cairo. This is serving the latter in seeking the approval of the Islamist factions in Egypt.” From her point of view, Sherine Elghatit, Professor of Political Science at AUC, “the attack on the Israeli Embassy in Cairo was directed against the Egyptian Government more than Israel. People were mad at the interim government for not taking a strong stand towards the death of the Egyptian soldiers. As for the exchange of Prisoners, the timing was a surprise. But it says a lot about the Israeli policies in the wake of the Arab Spring and the realization that things won’t be always on their own terms, they had to find a another way to proceed that is why we have witnessed such rapid developments on that front.”
As for the Security in Sinai, Mr. Tohamy stated, “in the recent years, Sinai is suffering from strategic and security vacuum, which comprises a predicament to all parties. This situation tempts many of the Salafist, Jihadist, regional and international security services to play an active role in Sinai. The recent incidents with the continuous attacks on the gas pipelines, the violence in Arish and Eilat operations all indicate the presence of new players in the Peninsula. This dilemma stems from the Peace Treaty of 1979 that restricts the Egyptian freedom in deploying more troops in Sinai. Yet, the negative impacts of these incidents on Israeli interests and security make the Israeli government, though hesitant, more open to negotiations aiming at increasing the Egyptian Army troops there. Moreover, a friendly Hamas will collaborate with Egypt in order to control the passage of Jihadist members from Gaza into Sinai. Hence, we can consider the last breakthroughs a shift in the Egyptian policy toward Hamas, but it is early to judge its parameters. And to sum up, the last events took place because of the interests involved to the other parties, not only the Egyptian efforts and definitely, if the internal situation in Egypt is more solid, we would achieve much more in our external affairs.”
“Secretive” Constitutional Declaration "
Egypt has witnessed a new Constitutional Declaration when SCAF issued a “Secretive” Constitutional Declaration on the 25th of February 2011. They said it is complementary to the previous Declarations issued to regulate steering the administration of the Republic until the people of Egypt elect a new Parliament and a new president.
This declaration consisted of one provision dealing with the electoral process and it addressed the allocation of seats in both houses of the parliament ( the people’s assembly and the Shoura Council). Under this provision, two thirds of seats of the People's Assembly and the Shura Council would be filled under the proportional list system and one third of seats will filled through the individual system.
SCAF issued the declaration and published it in the official gazette in isolation from all political forces in the country, which eventually lead to widespread condemnation from some of them as stated in Elmasry Elyoum newspaper on 28 September 2011 that “They (referring to SCAF) added that the decision to restrict publication of the declaration to the Official Gazette reflects a state of confusion within the military council. “They cannot just publish it without putting it up for a political dialogue,” said Mohamed al-Qassas of the Islamist Egyptian Trend Party.
While on the other hand, General Mamdouh Shaheen Assistant Minister of Defence for Legal Affairs and Member of SCAF stated to the Ahram Gate on the 30th of September that there was a need for this declaration because the previous declarations do not allow a change in the proportions allocated between those elected on the list and those elected as individuals. Moreover, he added that SCAF has an absolute power to issue constitutional declarations during the transitional period.
Now, Egypt had so far three constitutional declarations issued since the revolt of January 2011. The first Declaration was issued directly on 13th of February 2011 after the announcement that Mubarak had given up power and delegated SCAF to take over running the country until a new government is formed, the second Declaration was issued on the 31st of March 2011 after a public referendum that approved amendments to the 1971 Constitution which was already put on hold at the time. Hence, this dilemma presents several questions, whether the second constitution was legal or not? Is it true that SCAF has absolute power to issue declarations during the transitional period? What are the consequences of all these changes on the political, legal and economic situation of the country?
While seeking answers to these questions, Professor Sherine Elghatit from the Political Science Department at AUC stated that the main characteristic of a government in transition that it should only confine itself to the role of a care taker government. Therefore, it works in accordance with the existing laws and regulations because there are no legitimate legislative institutions in place. However, in the case of Egypt, the Consecutive Constitutional Declarations failed to set a time frame to the transitional period. Furthermore, it has granted SCAF the absolute power to issue decrees of laws without any restrictions to the types of legislation they can issue or with regard to their substance. In fact, this is in contradiction with the revolutionary legitimacy that requires confining the promulgation of laws to those that represent the will of the revolutionary people. This further entails that these laws are those concerned with the upcoming elections only, like the electoral and parties laws.”
She added, “Concerning the consecutive Constitutional Declarations, the Egyptian people were dragged to the referendum without real use or benefit to the democratic process. Furthermore, the legitimacy of the Second Constitutional Declaration is subject to doubts because it has altered the will of the people. ”
As for the consequences of these measures on the situation of Egypt, she stated “Granting SCAF absolute power to issue legislation without any restrictions leads to a worrisome legal and political situation. It opens the door to amend any of the existing legislation in education, health, personal Status, commerce, tourism and others, which freezes the flow of investments into Egypt, because the foreign and local investors are uncertain to what may take place between one day and another. Hence, unfortunately the poor and not the rich people will be the most affected by that situation. They will lose their jobs and they won’t find a substitute because no new jobs are created in the absence of the flow of investments. Furthermore, if the legal uncertainty phase is prolonged we will witness further deterioration and more investments that will close down and pull out of the Egyptian market.”
This declaration consisted of one provision dealing with the electoral process and it addressed the allocation of seats in both houses of the parliament ( the people’s assembly and the Shoura Council). Under this provision, two thirds of seats of the People's Assembly and the Shura Council would be filled under the proportional list system and one third of seats will filled through the individual system.
SCAF issued the declaration and published it in the official gazette in isolation from all political forces in the country, which eventually lead to widespread condemnation from some of them as stated in Elmasry Elyoum newspaper on 28 September 2011 that “They (referring to SCAF) added that the decision to restrict publication of the declaration to the Official Gazette reflects a state of confusion within the military council. “They cannot just publish it without putting it up for a political dialogue,” said Mohamed al-Qassas of the Islamist Egyptian Trend Party.
While on the other hand, General Mamdouh Shaheen Assistant Minister of Defence for Legal Affairs and Member of SCAF stated to the Ahram Gate on the 30th of September that there was a need for this declaration because the previous declarations do not allow a change in the proportions allocated between those elected on the list and those elected as individuals. Moreover, he added that SCAF has an absolute power to issue constitutional declarations during the transitional period.
Now, Egypt had so far three constitutional declarations issued since the revolt of January 2011. The first Declaration was issued directly on 13th of February 2011 after the announcement that Mubarak had given up power and delegated SCAF to take over running the country until a new government is formed, the second Declaration was issued on the 31st of March 2011 after a public referendum that approved amendments to the 1971 Constitution which was already put on hold at the time. Hence, this dilemma presents several questions, whether the second constitution was legal or not? Is it true that SCAF has absolute power to issue declarations during the transitional period? What are the consequences of all these changes on the political, legal and economic situation of the country?
While seeking answers to these questions, Professor Sherine Elghatit from the Political Science Department at AUC stated that the main characteristic of a government in transition that it should only confine itself to the role of a care taker government. Therefore, it works in accordance with the existing laws and regulations because there are no legitimate legislative institutions in place. However, in the case of Egypt, the Consecutive Constitutional Declarations failed to set a time frame to the transitional period. Furthermore, it has granted SCAF the absolute power to issue decrees of laws without any restrictions to the types of legislation they can issue or with regard to their substance. In fact, this is in contradiction with the revolutionary legitimacy that requires confining the promulgation of laws to those that represent the will of the revolutionary people. This further entails that these laws are those concerned with the upcoming elections only, like the electoral and parties laws.”
She added, “Concerning the consecutive Constitutional Declarations, the Egyptian people were dragged to the referendum without real use or benefit to the democratic process. Furthermore, the legitimacy of the Second Constitutional Declaration is subject to doubts because it has altered the will of the people. ”
As for the consequences of these measures on the situation of Egypt, she stated “Granting SCAF absolute power to issue legislation without any restrictions leads to a worrisome legal and political situation. It opens the door to amend any of the existing legislation in education, health, personal Status, commerce, tourism and others, which freezes the flow of investments into Egypt, because the foreign and local investors are uncertain to what may take place between one day and another. Hence, unfortunately the poor and not the rich people will be the most affected by that situation. They will lose their jobs and they won’t find a substitute because no new jobs are created in the absence of the flow of investments. Furthermore, if the legal uncertainty phase is prolonged we will witness further deterioration and more investments that will close down and pull out of the Egyptian market.”
The Salemy’s Document 2011
While the elections are approaching, a heated ongoing debate is taking place on another attempt to issue a new document for Supra Constitutional Principles came to light last week by the Deputy Prime Minister, Dr. Ali Elselmy.
The Salemy’s Document addressed rights and freedoms and also granted the Military a prominent position in the new constitution; Articles 9 and 10 put the Military as the sole guarantor of the constitutional legitimacy in the country, its budget shall be confidential and not to be discussed in the Parliament. Moreover, the Document attempted to lay criteria for choosing the 100 members of the Constitutional Assembly, 80% of them will be chosen and only 20% left to the Parliament to. After concerns rose by political factions, on 14 November, Dr. Elselmy deleted from Article 9 and 10 that the Army is the sole guarantor of the constitution and its budget will be reviewed by the National Security Council chaired by the president.
On Sunday 13 November, the Democratic Coalition for Egypt met in the premises of the freedom and justice party to discuss the document and issued a statement agreeing to abide by the Al Azhar document, confirming that the Constitutional Assembly should encompass all factions in the community and that issues of the Military that concerns the national security should be taken into consideration while drafting the new constitution. Commenting on this Statement, Mr. Abu ElEla Mady, the Chief of ElWasat Party, that shared in drafting the Statement, stated that the Coalition agreed with most of the articles of the Document, except for articles 9 and 10. He ensured, “the Armed Forces, as part of the executive branch of the State has to abide by the Constitution and the law and its budget has to be discussed by the Parliament in confidential meetings as is the case democratic systems.”
Mr. Shahir George, Member of Egypt Freedom Party who is running in the upcoming elections as part of the Coalition of the Revolution Continues, stated, “we are against granting the Military immunity or granting it rights in choosing the members of the Constitutional Assembly. The amendment to review the military budget by the National Security Council is a good step, yet the target should be its revision by the Parliament. The timing of the Document is bad due to the proximity to the elections.” He confirmed, “we support a consensus guidelines Document with the approval of the Egyptian people in a referendum. Parliament members should choose the members of the Assembly whether from among them or outside. but we are against any imposition of certain members by SCAF.” Dr. Dina Shehata, Senior Researcher at Al-Ahram Centre for Political and Strategic Studies stressed that the problem lied in the process. Dr. Elselmy prepared Constitutional Principles in the absence of any dialogue with political factions in a manner of “take it or leave it”. Furthermore, Dr. Shehata said, “it is not foreseen that the new constitution will come out without granting the military immunities, but it comes up as a compromise not enforced by the Government.” Also, Dr. Samer Soliman, Founding Member of the Egyptian Democratic Social Party, agreed that there process is the problem. He said, “the party refuses any a political role for the Military. We are against any military or religious state and contrary to the Islamite factions, we believe that drafting the constitution should not be left to the faction with the majority in the parliament.” He added, “we can agree to a consensus document that guarantees the political rights and democracy, with guarantees that all will abide by it.” He confirmed, “the amendments are steps in the right direction towards our goals. Islamite factions predict that they will gain the majority in the parliament and they want to dominate writing the new constitution. They endorsed the Azhar document because of its general nature.”
Commenting on the whole difference, Professor Ezzedine Fishere of AUC said “liberals want a document to serve as a guarantee to respect democracy and freedoms. This is the most important factor for them because it helps alleviate their worries from the Islamite factions. On the contrary, Islamite factions don’t want to give any concessions hoping that they will win the majority so they’ve more space to maneuver. In fact, Islamite factions agreed to join forces with other political factions in opposing the expansion of the role of the military isolate SCAF and the Government predicting that this fight may kill the document. However, if the liberals agreed to the document then the Islamite factions will be left alone. By all means, this document is not the right place to discuss the role of the Military, SCAF is still in power and we have ample time to discuss this issue at length.”
The Salemy’s Document addressed rights and freedoms and also granted the Military a prominent position in the new constitution; Articles 9 and 10 put the Military as the sole guarantor of the constitutional legitimacy in the country, its budget shall be confidential and not to be discussed in the Parliament. Moreover, the Document attempted to lay criteria for choosing the 100 members of the Constitutional Assembly, 80% of them will be chosen and only 20% left to the Parliament to. After concerns rose by political factions, on 14 November, Dr. Elselmy deleted from Article 9 and 10 that the Army is the sole guarantor of the constitution and its budget will be reviewed by the National Security Council chaired by the president.
On Sunday 13 November, the Democratic Coalition for Egypt met in the premises of the freedom and justice party to discuss the document and issued a statement agreeing to abide by the Al Azhar document, confirming that the Constitutional Assembly should encompass all factions in the community and that issues of the Military that concerns the national security should be taken into consideration while drafting the new constitution. Commenting on this Statement, Mr. Abu ElEla Mady, the Chief of ElWasat Party, that shared in drafting the Statement, stated that the Coalition agreed with most of the articles of the Document, except for articles 9 and 10. He ensured, “the Armed Forces, as part of the executive branch of the State has to abide by the Constitution and the law and its budget has to be discussed by the Parliament in confidential meetings as is the case democratic systems.”
Mr. Shahir George, Member of Egypt Freedom Party who is running in the upcoming elections as part of the Coalition of the Revolution Continues, stated, “we are against granting the Military immunity or granting it rights in choosing the members of the Constitutional Assembly. The amendment to review the military budget by the National Security Council is a good step, yet the target should be its revision by the Parliament. The timing of the Document is bad due to the proximity to the elections.” He confirmed, “we support a consensus guidelines Document with the approval of the Egyptian people in a referendum. Parliament members should choose the members of the Assembly whether from among them or outside. but we are against any imposition of certain members by SCAF.” Dr. Dina Shehata, Senior Researcher at Al-Ahram Centre for Political and Strategic Studies stressed that the problem lied in the process. Dr. Elselmy prepared Constitutional Principles in the absence of any dialogue with political factions in a manner of “take it or leave it”. Furthermore, Dr. Shehata said, “it is not foreseen that the new constitution will come out without granting the military immunities, but it comes up as a compromise not enforced by the Government.” Also, Dr. Samer Soliman, Founding Member of the Egyptian Democratic Social Party, agreed that there process is the problem. He said, “the party refuses any a political role for the Military. We are against any military or religious state and contrary to the Islamite factions, we believe that drafting the constitution should not be left to the faction with the majority in the parliament.” He added, “we can agree to a consensus document that guarantees the political rights and democracy, with guarantees that all will abide by it.” He confirmed, “the amendments are steps in the right direction towards our goals. Islamite factions predict that they will gain the majority in the parliament and they want to dominate writing the new constitution. They endorsed the Azhar document because of its general nature.”
Commenting on the whole difference, Professor Ezzedine Fishere of AUC said “liberals want a document to serve as a guarantee to respect democracy and freedoms. This is the most important factor for them because it helps alleviate their worries from the Islamite factions. On the contrary, Islamite factions don’t want to give any concessions hoping that they will win the majority so they’ve more space to maneuver. In fact, Islamite factions agreed to join forces with other political factions in opposing the expansion of the role of the military isolate SCAF and the Government predicting that this fight may kill the document. However, if the liberals agreed to the document then the Islamite factions will be left alone. By all means, this document is not the right place to discuss the role of the Military, SCAF is still in power and we have ample time to discuss this issue at length.”
IMBABA
بعد أقل من 24 ساعة من نشر المقال حول خطوات الإصلاح الأمنى نشبت معارك فى منطقة إمبابة بين المسلمين والأقباط فى المنطقة مما أسفر عن قتلى وجرحى وتحول المكان إلى منطقة حرب حتى فجر اليوم التالى بعد تدخل القوات الأمنية بعنف لفض الإشتباك، مما أدى إلى أن انتابنى الشعور بأننى "أنفخ فى قربة مقطوعة"، وبدأ نوع من اليأس والإحباط يندس فى مخيلتى واسترجعت مقولة زعيم الأمة سعد زغلول عن مرضه إن "مفيش فايدة"، إلا أن رؤية ما يحدث على كورنيش النيل أمام مبنى الإذاعة والتلفزيون بماسبيرو وانتشار الأمن المركزى لتأمين المتظاهرين جعلنى استحضر ما قاله نابليون بأن "مفيش مستحيل".
وبالفعل أنا على قناعة تامة بأن مفيش مستحيل وأن الوضع الأمنى سوف يتحسن بعد تدهور، حتى مع توقع المزيد، إلا أن تحسين الوضع الأمنى يقتضى وبلا جدال إلى جانب إصلاح القطاع الأمنى تكريس مفهوم سيادة القانون من قبل الجميع، المواطنين والقائمين على تنفيذ القانون. فى الوضع المصرى الراهن، نحن فى أمس حاجة لتنفيذ قانون العقوبات والقوانين الأخرى المرتبطة بها وغيرها من القوانين الخاصة بالحفاظ على الأمن العام فى البلاد.
وبالفعل أنا على قناعة تامة بأن مفيش مستحيل وأن الوضع الأمنى سوف يتحسن بعد تدهور، حتى مع توقع المزيد، إلا أن تحسين الوضع الأمنى يقتضى وبلا جدال إلى جانب إصلاح القطاع الأمنى تكريس مفهوم سيادة القانون من قبل الجميع، المواطنين والقائمين على تنفيذ القانون. فى الوضع المصرى الراهن، نحن فى أمس حاجة لتنفيذ قانون العقوبات والقوانين الأخرى المرتبطة بها وغيرها من القوانين الخاصة بالحفاظ على الأمن العام فى البلاد.
EU Parliament Decision on Maspero incident 2011
Protection of Freedom of Religions and rights of minorities or interference in the internal affairs of the State, within those parameters the EU Parliament passed a draft resolution which was the last in many measures taken by the International Community as a response to a protest against religious discrimination turned into a bloodbath in Maspero Area in Cairo on 9 October 2011.
The EU Parliament, On 27 October 2011, passed a draft resolution on the situation in Egypt and Syria, in particular the Christian Minorities. The resolution strongly condemned the killing of protestors in Egypt, expressed solidarity with the Egyptian people in their struggle for democracy, while noting that since March 2011 tens of thousands of Copts have reportedly left Egypt called upon SCAF to put an end to the emergency law, as it violates the rights of freedom of expression, association and assembly and urged the Egyptian Government and authorities to put an end without delay to military trials of civilians.
In her address to the Parliament, Catherine Ashton, Vice-President of the Commission/High Representative of the Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy stated, “We were all shocked and appalled by the violence against a peaceful demonstration by the Coptic Christian community that led to the death of 25 people, with more than 300 injured.
These clashes run contrary to the whole spirit and goals of the revolution and the aspirations of all Egyptians – of all backgrounds and beliefs.” She added, “I made a statement calling for calm and restraint and an investigation so that those responsible for the violence can be brought to justice.
I urged and I urged the authorities to protect the right to demonstrate peacefully, and the right to freedom of religion or belief – one of the most fundamental of all human rights.” Commenting on this, a Diplomat from a European who deals with EU Parliament matters, who preferred to stay anonymous, stated “the resolutions of the EU Parliament are recommendations and not mandatory. They are directed to the European Commission and the Member States. These resolutions are used more as public relations tool because in many incidents the views of the Parliament do not coincide with those of the Commission. They are more of political messages to States and not many implications on the EC relations with Egypt will take place at this stage based on that resolution.” Contrary to that, Ms Heba Morayef of Human Rights Watch confirmed that the impact of such resolutions should not be underestimated because although they are non-binding, the resolutions of the EU Parliament have impact on the EC and policies of its member States. “The Parliament is pushing its Member States to be adopt a more robust approach with regard to supporting Democracy and Human Rights.”
While this is not the first time the EU Parliament tackled the issue of human rights in Egypt, freedom of expression as well as the rights of minorities, but this was comprehensible under the Mubarak regime. The Mubarak regime and its repressive approaches were behind the 25th of January revolt and they have always refused such resolutions as contradictory to the principle of non-interference in the internal affairs of States. Yet, reflecting that no change has taken place so far, the surprise in Ashton’s address was in relation to the situation after the revolution. This surprise is shared by many human rights organizations, including Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, who called for accountability to those who were behind killing the peaceful demonstrators. Ambassador Fathy El Shazly, Former Assistant Minister of Foreign Affairs for European Affairs, contradicted the views of many officials that the principle of non-interference in the internal affairs of States is absolute. He stated, “Egypt must respect human rights and freedoms in order to avoid any criticism from the international community. The era of absolute power of the state against its citizens is over and States should not be left to torture and violate the human rights of citizens without accountability. It is time for a clear law to regulate the issue of places of worship. Building churches illegally is not appropriate, but the lack of necessary regulations to build places of warship is a problem. If we solve the problem, Egypt will not be subject to international criticism.” He added, “We cannot adopt two standards, Egypt was a locomotive in the Organisation of Islamic Conference in order to have international intervention to save the Muslim minorities in Bosnia and Kosovo against the oppression of the Yugoslav regime at the time. Hence, we should set our internal affairs in place in order to avoid international accountability.” Ms Morayef stressed that the continuation of discrimination against Christians with regard to the building and renovation of their places of worship leads to the violations. She added, “In the last 4 years, incidents of sectarian violence were all concerning building legally unauthorized churches. Recently, the government acknowledged that this issue should be solved through the unified law for places of worship to replace the ancient law that is still in force until now. Moreover, the continuation of the unfair law will lead to further breaches to it by building other unauthorized churches.”
In Egypt in the aftermath of the incident, SCAF requested the Government, on 10 October 2011, to establish an independent commission of inquiry in order to investigate the events and supposedly bring those accountable to justice. In the evening of the same day, the Government established the Commission and issued decisions with regard to the speedy conclusion of the unified law for warship places and amendments to the Penal Code to consider discrimination as a crime. Moreover, the Supreme Council for Human Rights has established another independent Commission of inquiry in the Maspero incidents. Both reports are expected to be published by the end of the week. Ms Morayef confirmed that a problem exists in all the incidents of using disproportionate violence against peaceful demonstrators, not only the Christian demonstrators in Maspero, and the lack of accountability to those who do that. This constitutes a clear violation to the rule of law and provides impunity to the perpetrators. She confirmed, “The way the state has been dealing with incidents of sectarian violence is not satisfactory. We didn’t see indictments in all the incidents that took place since the church of the Two Saints explosion in Alexandria in Christmas last year, passing through Atfih, Embaba ElMenya and now waiting for the outcome of the Maspero inquiry. The rule of law and fighting impunity should replace the old policy of using sectarian violence to achieve political goals, while leaving the victims in a weaker position subject to vindication of their rights by the State.”
The EU Parliament, On 27 October 2011, passed a draft resolution on the situation in Egypt and Syria, in particular the Christian Minorities. The resolution strongly condemned the killing of protestors in Egypt, expressed solidarity with the Egyptian people in their struggle for democracy, while noting that since March 2011 tens of thousands of Copts have reportedly left Egypt called upon SCAF to put an end to the emergency law, as it violates the rights of freedom of expression, association and assembly and urged the Egyptian Government and authorities to put an end without delay to military trials of civilians.
In her address to the Parliament, Catherine Ashton, Vice-President of the Commission/High Representative of the Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy stated, “We were all shocked and appalled by the violence against a peaceful demonstration by the Coptic Christian community that led to the death of 25 people, with more than 300 injured.
These clashes run contrary to the whole spirit and goals of the revolution and the aspirations of all Egyptians – of all backgrounds and beliefs.” She added, “I made a statement calling for calm and restraint and an investigation so that those responsible for the violence can be brought to justice.
I urged and I urged the authorities to protect the right to demonstrate peacefully, and the right to freedom of religion or belief – one of the most fundamental of all human rights.” Commenting on this, a Diplomat from a European who deals with EU Parliament matters, who preferred to stay anonymous, stated “the resolutions of the EU Parliament are recommendations and not mandatory. They are directed to the European Commission and the Member States. These resolutions are used more as public relations tool because in many incidents the views of the Parliament do not coincide with those of the Commission. They are more of political messages to States and not many implications on the EC relations with Egypt will take place at this stage based on that resolution.” Contrary to that, Ms Heba Morayef of Human Rights Watch confirmed that the impact of such resolutions should not be underestimated because although they are non-binding, the resolutions of the EU Parliament have impact on the EC and policies of its member States. “The Parliament is pushing its Member States to be adopt a more robust approach with regard to supporting Democracy and Human Rights.”
While this is not the first time the EU Parliament tackled the issue of human rights in Egypt, freedom of expression as well as the rights of minorities, but this was comprehensible under the Mubarak regime. The Mubarak regime and its repressive approaches were behind the 25th of January revolt and they have always refused such resolutions as contradictory to the principle of non-interference in the internal affairs of States. Yet, reflecting that no change has taken place so far, the surprise in Ashton’s address was in relation to the situation after the revolution. This surprise is shared by many human rights organizations, including Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, who called for accountability to those who were behind killing the peaceful demonstrators. Ambassador Fathy El Shazly, Former Assistant Minister of Foreign Affairs for European Affairs, contradicted the views of many officials that the principle of non-interference in the internal affairs of States is absolute. He stated, “Egypt must respect human rights and freedoms in order to avoid any criticism from the international community. The era of absolute power of the state against its citizens is over and States should not be left to torture and violate the human rights of citizens without accountability. It is time for a clear law to regulate the issue of places of worship. Building churches illegally is not appropriate, but the lack of necessary regulations to build places of warship is a problem. If we solve the problem, Egypt will not be subject to international criticism.” He added, “We cannot adopt two standards, Egypt was a locomotive in the Organisation of Islamic Conference in order to have international intervention to save the Muslim minorities in Bosnia and Kosovo against the oppression of the Yugoslav regime at the time. Hence, we should set our internal affairs in place in order to avoid international accountability.” Ms Morayef stressed that the continuation of discrimination against Christians with regard to the building and renovation of their places of worship leads to the violations. She added, “In the last 4 years, incidents of sectarian violence were all concerning building legally unauthorized churches. Recently, the government acknowledged that this issue should be solved through the unified law for places of worship to replace the ancient law that is still in force until now. Moreover, the continuation of the unfair law will lead to further breaches to it by building other unauthorized churches.”
In Egypt in the aftermath of the incident, SCAF requested the Government, on 10 October 2011, to establish an independent commission of inquiry in order to investigate the events and supposedly bring those accountable to justice. In the evening of the same day, the Government established the Commission and issued decisions with regard to the speedy conclusion of the unified law for warship places and amendments to the Penal Code to consider discrimination as a crime. Moreover, the Supreme Council for Human Rights has established another independent Commission of inquiry in the Maspero incidents. Both reports are expected to be published by the end of the week. Ms Morayef confirmed that a problem exists in all the incidents of using disproportionate violence against peaceful demonstrators, not only the Christian demonstrators in Maspero, and the lack of accountability to those who do that. This constitutes a clear violation to the rule of law and provides impunity to the perpetrators. She confirmed, “The way the state has been dealing with incidents of sectarian violence is not satisfactory. We didn’t see indictments in all the incidents that took place since the church of the Two Saints explosion in Alexandria in Christmas last year, passing through Atfih, Embaba ElMenya and now waiting for the outcome of the Maspero inquiry. The rule of law and fighting impunity should replace the old policy of using sectarian violence to achieve political goals, while leaving the victims in a weaker position subject to vindication of their rights by the State.”
latest news!
In an unusual briefing evidently aimed at Washington, Gen. Mukhtar al-Mulla of the ruling council asserted that the initial results of elections for the People’s Assembly do not represent the full Egyptian public, in part because well-organized factions of Islamists were dominating the voting. The comments, to foreign reporters and not the Egyptian public, may have been intended to persuade Washington to back off its call for civilian rule.
hence... Tahrir is not representative of people .. parliament doesnt represent people.. who does? you ya ro7 mama ??
hence... Tahrir is not representative of people .. parliament doesnt represent people.. who does? you ya ro7 mama ??
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)